Ehsani Amir Hooshang, Noormohammadpoor Pedram, Abdolreza Mona, Balighi Kamran, Arianian Zaynab, Daklan Soroush
Razi Hospital, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran,
Razi Hospital, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Arch Iran Med. 2014 Oct;17(10):657-60.
The combination of pulsed dye laser (PDL) and topical propranolol are used with variable effectiveness for the treatment of infantile hemangiomas (IH), particularly for superficial lesions.
OBJECTIVE(S): The aim of this study was to investigate whether the therapeutic efficacy of prescribing topical propranolol along with PDL was superior to PDL therapy alone in the treatment of IH.
A total of 19 patients with IH were recruited to the study. Among them, nine patients were treated with PDL, 3 sessions 4 weeks apart, and 10 patients underwent PDL treatment alongside with topical propranolol for 12 weeks. The therapeutic efficacies of each regimen were assessed by comparing photographs of skin lesions before and after the treatment based on the cessation of the lesion growth, reduction in the lesion size, and lightening of the lesion color.
No side-effect was reported by the parents. Among nine patients in PDL group, only two (22%) had excellent clearance, one (11%) had good, three (30%) had weak, and three (30%) had no responses. On the other hand, among 10 patients who were treated with both the PDL and topical propranolol, five (50%) showed excellent responses and five (50%) displayed good responses. Statistical data analysis with Mann-Whitney test revealed a significant difference in the clinical response between two treatment groups.
The combination of PDL and topical propranolol seem to be a safe and effective therapy, and results in better clinical responses in the treatment of IH than PDL therapy alone.
脉冲染料激光(PDL)与外用普萘洛尔联合使用治疗婴儿血管瘤(IH)的效果各异,尤其对于浅表性病变。
本研究旨在探讨在治疗IH时,外用普萘洛尔联合PDL的治疗效果是否优于单纯PDL治疗。
共招募19例IH患者。其中,9例患者接受PDL治疗,每4周进行3次治疗;10例患者在接受PDL治疗的同时外用普萘洛尔,持续12周。通过比较治疗前后皮肤病变的照片,依据病变生长停止、病变大小缩小及病变颜色变浅来评估每种治疗方案的疗效。
家长未报告有副作用。在PDL组的9例患者中,只有2例(22%)完全清除良好,1例(11%)较好,3例(30%)效果欠佳,3例(30%)无反应。另一方面,在接受PDL和外用普萘洛尔联合治疗的10例患者中,5例(50%)反应良好,5例(50%)反应较好。采用曼-惠特尼检验进行统计数据分析显示,两个治疗组之间的临床反应存在显著差异。
PDL与外用普萘洛尔联合使用似乎是一种安全有效的治疗方法,在治疗IH方面比单纯PDL治疗产生更好的临床反应。