Larson Elysia, Hermosilla Sabrina, Kimweri Angela, Mbaruku Godfrey M, Kruk Margaret E
Health Policy & Management, Columbia University, 600 W, 168th St, New York, NY 10032, USA.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2014 Oct 18;14:483. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-14-483.
Patients' reported opinions of the health system need to be understood in order to provide patient-centered care. We investigated determinants of women's ratings of the quality of care during their most recent facility delivery.
We conducted a census of all deliveries in the 6 weeks to 12 months preceding the survey, in villages served by 24 primary care clinics in rural Pwani Region, Tanzania. Women who had delivered children in a study facility were included in this analysis (n = 855). We interviewed women about demographic and obstetric factors and the quality of their obstetric care using a structured questionnaire. We created a composite index of perceived quality from six quality questions. We also assessed the functioning of the local health clinic using structured surveys. We used a multi-level model to analyze factors associated with women's rating of the quality of care during delivery.
14% of respondents rated the overall quality of care received during delivery as excellent. Women who listened to the radio daily reported lower quality composite scores (β: -0.99, p < 0.001). Women who reported receiving more services in ANC had higher quality scores (β: 0.46, p = 0.001), as did women receiving more delivery services (β: 0.55, p < 0.001). Women who reported disrespect and abuse during delivery had significantly lower quality scores (β: -4.13, p < 0.001).
A woman's expectations and prior and current experiences influence her perception of the quality of care she received. Health facility characteristics did not influence ratings of overall quality. Focusing on improving the process rather than inputs of service delivery during ANC visits and delivery may increase perceived quality of delivery care in low-resource settings.
ISRCTN17107760.
为了提供以患者为中心的护理,需要了解患者对卫生系统的报告意见。我们调查了女性对其最近一次机构分娩期间护理质量评分的决定因素。
我们对坦桑尼亚滨海省农村地区24家初级保健诊所服务的村庄在调查前6周至12个月内的所有分娩进行了普查。在研究机构分娩的妇女被纳入本分析(n = 855)。我们使用结构化问卷询问了妇女的人口统计学和产科因素以及她们的产科护理质量。我们从六个质量问题中创建了一个感知质量综合指数。我们还使用结构化调查评估了当地卫生诊所的运作情况。我们使用多层次模型分析与女性分娩期间护理质量评分相关的因素。
14%的受访者将分娩期间接受的护理总体质量评为优秀。每天听收音机的女性报告的综合质量得分较低(β:-0.99,p < 0.001)。报告在产前保健中获得更多服务的女性质量得分较高(β:0.46,p = 0.001),接受更多分娩服务的女性也是如此(β:0.55,p < 0.001)。报告在分娩期间受到不尊重和虐待的女性质量得分显著较低(β:-4.13,p < 0.001)。
女性的期望以及既往和当前经历会影响她对所接受护理质量的感知。医疗机构的特征并未影响总体质量评分。在资源匮乏地区,关注改善产前保健就诊和分娩期间的服务提供过程而非投入,可能会提高对分娩护理的感知质量。
ISRCTN17107760。