Goodman Anna, Page Angie S, Cooper Ashley R
Faculty of Epidemiology and Population Health, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, Keppel Street, London WC1E 7HT, UK.
Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2014 Oct 23;11:84. doi: 10.1186/1479-5868-11-84.
It has been proposed that introducing daylight saving measures could increase children's physical activity, but there exists little research on this issue. This study therefore examined associations between time of sunset and activity levels, including using the bi-annual 'changing of the clocks' as a natural experiment.
23,188 children aged 5-16 years from 15 studies in nine countries were brought together in the International Children's Accelerometry Database. 439 of these children were of particular interest for our analyses as they contributed data both immediately before and after the clocks changed. All children provided objectively-measured physical activity data from Actigraph accelerometers, and we used their average physical activity level (accelerometer counts per minute) as our primary outcome. Date of accelerometer data collection was matched to time of sunset, and to weather characteristics including daily precipitation, humidity, wind speed and temperature.
Adjusting for child and weather covariates, we found that longer evening daylight was independently associated with a small increase in daily physical activity. Consistent with a causal interpretation, the magnitude of these associations was largest in the late afternoon and early evening and these associations were also evident when comparing the same child just before and just after the clocks changed. These associations were, however, only consistently observed in the five mainland European, four English and two Australian samples (adjusted, pooled effect sizes 0.03-0.07 standard deviations per hour of additional evening daylight). In some settings there was some evidence of larger associations between daylength and physical activity in boys. There was no evidence of interactions with weight status or maternal education, and inconsistent findings for interactions with age.
In Europe and Australia, evening daylight seems to play a causal role in increasing children's activity in a relatively equitable manner. Although the average increase in activity is small in absolute terms, these increases apply across all children in a population. Moreover, these small effect sizes actually compare relatively favourably with the typical effect of intensive, individual-level interventions. We therefore conclude that, by shifting the physical activity mean of the entire population, the introduction of additional daylight saving measures could yield worthwhile public health benefits.
有人提出采取夏令时措施可能会增加儿童的身体活动量,但关于这个问题的研究很少。因此,本研究考察了日落时间与活动水平之间的关联,包括将一年两次的“时钟调整”作为一项自然实验。
来自9个国家15项研究的23188名5至16岁儿童被纳入国际儿童加速度计数据库。其中439名儿童对我们的分析尤为重要,因为他们在时钟调整前后都提供了数据。所有儿童都提供了通过Actigraph加速度计客观测量的身体活动数据,我们将他们的平均身体活动水平(每分钟加速度计计数)作为主要结果。加速度计数据收集日期与日落时间以及包括每日降水量、湿度、风速和温度在内的天气特征相匹配。
在对儿童和天气协变量进行调整后,我们发现傍晚较长的日照时间与每日身体活动量的小幅增加独立相关。与因果解释一致,这些关联的幅度在下午晚些时候和傍晚最为明显,并且在比较同一个儿童在时钟调整前后的数据时也很明显。然而,这些关联仅在欧洲大陆的5个、英国的4个和澳大利亚的2个样本中一致观察到(调整后的合并效应大小为每增加一小时傍晚日照时间0.03 - 0.07标准差)。在某些情况下,有证据表明男孩的日照时长与身体活动之间的关联更大。没有证据表明与体重状况或母亲教育程度存在相互作用,与年龄的相互作用结果不一致。
在欧洲和澳大利亚,傍晚日照似乎以相对公平的方式在增加儿童活动方面起到了因果作用。尽管绝对活动量的平均增加幅度较小,但这些增加适用于人群中的所有儿童。此外,这些较小的效应大小实际上与强化的个体层面干预的典型效果相比相对有利。因此,我们得出结论,通过改变整个人口的身体活动均值,采取额外的夏令时措施可能会带来有价值的公共卫生效益。