Kosieradzki Maciej, Jakubowska-Winecka Anna, Feliksiak Michal, Kawalec Ilona, Zawilinska Ewa, Danielewicz Roman, Czerwinski Jaroslaw, Malkowski Piotr, Rowiński Wojciech
Department of General and Transplantation Surgery, Medical University of Warsaw, 02-006 Warsaw, Poland.
Department of Health Psychology, Children's Memorial Health Institute, 00-999 Warsaw, Poland.
J Transplant. 2014;2014:296912. doi: 10.1155/2014/296912. Epub 2014 Sep 30.
Public attitude toward deceased donor organ recovery in Poland is quite positive, with only 15% opposing to donation of their own organs, yet actual donation rate is only 16/pmp. Moreover, donation rate varies greatly (from 5 to 28 pmp) in different regions of the country. To identify the barriers of organ donation, we surveyed 587 physicians involved in brain death diagnosis from regions with low (LDR) and high donation rates (HDR). Physicians from LDR were twice more reluctant to start diagnostic procedure when clinical signs of brain death were present (14% versus 5.5% physicians from HDR who would not diagnose death, resp.). Twenty-five percent of LDR physicians (as opposed to 12% of physicians from HDR) would either continue with intensive therapy or confirm brain death and limit to the so-called minimal therapy. Only 32% of LDR physicians would proceed with brain death diagnosis regardless of organ donation, compared to 67% in HDR. When donation was not an option, mechanical ventilation would be continued more often in LDR regions (43% versus 26.7%; P < 0.01). In conclusion, low donation activity seems to be mostly due to medical staff attitude.
波兰公众对已故捐赠者器官获取的态度相当积极,只有15%的人反对捐赠自己的器官,但实际捐赠率仅为每百万人口16例。此外,该国不同地区的捐赠率差异很大(从每百万人口5例到28例)。为了确定器官捐赠的障碍,我们对来自低捐赠率(LDR)和高捐赠率(HDR)地区的587名参与脑死亡诊断的医生进行了调查。当出现脑死亡临床体征时,来自LDR的医生开始诊断程序的意愿要低两倍(分别为14%和5.5%的HDR医生不会诊断死亡)。25%的LDR医生(而HDR医生为12%)会继续进行强化治疗或确认脑死亡并限制在所谓的最低限度治疗。无论是否进行器官捐赠,只有32%的LDR医生会进行脑死亡诊断,而HDR地区这一比例为67%。当不考虑捐赠时,LDR地区更常继续进行机械通气(43%对26.7%;P<0.01)。总之,低捐赠活动似乎主要归因于医务人员的态度。