Combs Hannah L, Berry David T R, Pape Theresa, Babcock-Parziale Judith, Smith Bridget, Schleenbaker Randal, Shandera-Ochsner Anne, Harp Jordan P, High Walter M
1 Department of Psychology, University of Kentucky , Lexington, Kentucky.
2 Edward Hines Jr. Hospital , Hines, Illinois.
J Neurotrauma. 2015 Jul 1;32(13):956-66. doi: 10.1089/neu.2014.3585. Epub 2015 Feb 26.
United States veterans of the Iraqi (Operation Iraqi Freedom [OIF]) and Afghanistan (Operation Enduring Freedom [OEF]) conflicts have frequently returned from deployment after sustaining mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) and enduring stressful events resulting in post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). A large number of returning service members have been diagnosed with both a history of mTBI and current PTSD. Substantial literature exists on the neuropsychological factors associated with mTBI and PTSD occurring separately; far less research has explored the combined effects of PTSD and mTBI. The current study employed neuropsychological and psychological measures in a sample of 251 OIF/OEF veterans to determine whether participants with a history of mTBI and current PTSD (mTBI+PTSD) have poorer cognitive and psychological outcomes than participants with mTBI only (mTBI-o), PTSD only (PTSD-o), or veteran controls (VC), when groups are comparable on intelligence quotient, education, and age. The mTBI+PTSD group performed more poorly than VC, mTBI-o, and PTSD-o groups on several neuropsychological measures. Effect size comparisons suggest small deleterious effects for mTBI-o on measures of processing speed and visual attention and small effects for PTSD-o on measures of verbal memory, with moderate effects for mTBI+PTSD on the same variables. Additionally, the mTBI+PTSD group was significantly more psychologically distressed than the PTSD-o group, and PTSD-o group was more distressed than VC and mTBI-o groups. These findings suggest that veterans with mTBI+PTSD perform significantly lower on neuropsychological and psychiatric measures than veterans with mTBI-o or PTSD-o. The results also raise the possibility of mild but persisting cognitive changes following mTBI sustained during deployment.
曾参与伊拉克战争(伊拉克自由行动[OIF])和阿富汗战争(持久自由行动[OEF])的美国退伍军人,在经历轻度创伤性脑损伤(mTBI)并承受导致创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的压力事件后,经常从部署任务中归来。大量归国军人被诊断既有mTBI病史又患有当前的PTSD。关于与mTBI和PTSD分别相关的神经心理学因素,已有大量文献;但探索PTSD和mTBI联合影响的研究要少得多。本研究对251名OIF/OEF退伍军人样本采用神经心理学和心理学测量方法,以确定有mTBI病史且患有当前PTSD(mTBI+PTSD)的参与者,在智商、教育程度和年龄相当的情况下,其认知和心理结果是否比仅患有mTBI(mTBI-o)、仅患有PTSD(PTSD-o)或退伍军人对照组(VC)的参与者更差。mTBI+PTSD组在多项神经心理学测量上的表现比VC组、mTBI-o组和PTSD-o组更差。效应量比较表明,mTBI-o对处理速度和视觉注意力测量有小的有害影响,PTSD-o对言语记忆测量有小的影响,而mTBI+PTSD对相同变量有中等影响。此外,mTBI+PTSD组的心理困扰明显比PTSD-o组更严重,且PTSD-o组比VC组和mTBI-o组更困扰。这些发现表明,患有mTBI+PTSD的退伍军人在神经心理学和精神病学测量上的表现明显低于患有mTBI-o或PTSD-o的退伍军人。研究结果还提出了在部署期间遭受mTBI后出现轻度但持续的认知变化的可能性。