Phrenological Controversy and the Medical Imagination: ‘A Modern Pythagorean’ in

The periodical press in the early nineteenth century was a site of dynamic exchange between men of science and men of letters, and was a particularly rich site of expression for medical ideas. This chapter explores the symbiotic relationship between the Blackwoodian prose fiction and the scientific and medical investigations of the Glaswegian surgeon and writer, Robert Macnish (1802–37), and in particular, his explorations of altered states of consciousness and phrenology. It is argued that his prose tales reveal the Blackwoodian ‘tale of terror’ to be an experimental template for the medical theorist and budding phrenologist, revealing problematic sites for medical hermeneutics in early nineteenth-century Scotland.