Humphries Tom, Kushalnagar Poorna, Mathur Gaurav, Napoli Donna Jo, Padden Carol, Rathmann Christian, Smith Scott
Department of Education Studies, University of California, San Diego, CA.
Chester F. Carlson Center for Imaging Sciences, Rochester Institute of Technology, NY.
J Med Speech Lang Pathol. 2014;21(2):107-125.
Cochlear implants (CI) have demonstrated success in improving young deaf children's speech and low-level speech awareness across a range of auditory functions, but this success is highly variable, and how this success correlates to high-level language development is even more variable. Prevalence on the success rate of CI as an outcome for language development is difficult to obtain because studies vary widely in methodology and variables of interest, and because not all cochlear implant technology (which continues to evolve) is the same. Still, even if the notion of treatment failure is limited narrowly to those who gain no auditory benefit from CI in that they cannot discriminate among ambient noises, the reported treatment failure rate is high enough to call into question the current lack of consideration of alternative approaches to ensure young deaf children's language development. Recent research has highlighted the risks of delaying language input during critical periods of brain development with concomitant consequences for cognitive and social skills. As a result, we propose that before, during, and after implantation deaf children learn a sign language along with a spoken language to ensure their maximal language development and optimal long-term developmental outcomes.
人工耳蜗(CI)已证明在改善听障幼儿一系列听觉功能方面的言语及低水平言语感知能力上取得了成功,但这种成功差异很大,而这种成功与高水平语言发展之间的关联更是千差万别。由于研究方法和关注变量差异很大,且并非所有人工耳蜗技术(仍在不断发展)都相同,因此很难获得人工耳蜗作为语言发展结果的成功率的普遍数据。即便将治疗失败狭义地定义为那些从人工耳蜗中未获得听觉益处(即无法区分环境噪声)的人,报告的治疗失败率也高到足以让人质疑当前对确保听障幼儿语言发展的替代方法缺乏考虑。最近的研究强调了在大脑发育关键期延迟语言输入的风险,以及随之而来的对认知和社交技能的影响。因此,我们建议在植入人工耳蜗之前、期间和之后,听障儿童学习手语和口语,以确保他们实现最大程度的语言发展和最佳的长期发育结果。