Irstea, UR LISC, 9 avenue Blaise Pascal, F-63178 Aubiere, France.
Environ Sci Technol. 2015 Jan 6;49(1):377-85. doi: 10.1021/es502128k. Epub 2014 Dec 12.
Sensitivity analysis (SA) is a significant tool for studying the robustness of results and their sensitivity to uncertainty factors in life cycle assessment (LCA). It highlights the most important set of model parameters to determine whether data quality needs to be improved, and to enhance interpretation of results. Interactions within the LCA calculation model and correlations within Life Cycle Inventory (LCI) input parameters are two main issues among the LCA calculation process. Here we propose a methodology for conducting a proper SA which takes into account the effects of these two issues. This study first presents the SA in an uncorrelated case, comparing local and independent global sensitivity analysis. Independent global sensitivity analysis aims to analyze the variability of results because of the variation of input parameters over the whole domain of uncertainty, together with interactions among input parameters. We then apply a dependent global sensitivity approach that makes minor modifications to traditional Sobol indices to address the correlation issue. Finally, we propose some guidelines for choosing the appropriate SA method depending on the characteristics of the model and the goals of the study. Our results clearly show that the choice of sensitivity methods should be made according to the magnitude of uncertainty and the degree of correlation.
敏感性分析(Sensitivity Analysis,简称 SA)是一种重要的工具,用于研究生命周期评价(LCA)中结果的稳健性及其对不确定性因素的敏感性。它突出了确定模型参数的最重要集合,以确定是否需要提高数据质量,并增强对结果的解释。在 LCA 计算模型内的相互作用和生命周期清单(LCI)输入参数内的相关性是 LCA 计算过程中的两个主要问题。在这里,我们提出了一种适当的 SA 方法,该方法考虑了这两个问题的影响。本研究首先在不相关的情况下进行了 SA,比较了局部和独立全局敏感性分析。独立全局敏感性分析旨在分析由于输入参数在整个不确定性范围内的变化以及输入参数之间的相互作用而导致的结果的可变性。然后,我们应用了一种依赖的全局敏感性方法,对传统的 Sobol 指数进行了微小的修改,以解决相关性问题。最后,我们根据模型的特点和研究的目标,提出了一些选择适当的 SA 方法的指南。我们的结果清楚地表明,应根据不确定性的大小和相关性的程度选择敏感性方法。