Mauthner Oliver E, De Luca Enza, Poole Jennifer M, Abbey Susan E, Shildrick Margrit, Gewarges Mena, Ross Heather J
University Health Network, Canada
University Health Network, Canada.
Health (London). 2015 Nov;19(6):578-94. doi: 10.1177/1363459314560067. Epub 2014 Nov 30.
Of heart transplant recipients, 30 per cent report ongoing or episodic emotional issues post-transplant, which are not attributable to medications or pathophysiological changes. To this end, our team theorized that cardiac transplantation introduces pressing new questions about how patients incorporate a transplanted heart into their sense of self and how this impacts their identity. The work of Merleau-Ponty provided the theoretical underpinning for this project as it rationalizes how corporeal changes affect one's self and offer an innovative framework to access these complex aspects of living with a transplanted heart. We used visual methodology and recorded 25 semi-structured interviews videographically. Both visual and verbal data were analyzed at the same time in an iterative process. The most common theme was that participants expressed a disruption to their own identity and bodily integrity. Additionally, participants reported interconnectedness with the donor, even when the transplanted heart was perceived as an intruder or stranger. Finally, transplant recipients were very vivid in their descriptions and speculation of how they imagined the donor. Receiving an anonymous donor organ from a stranger often leaves the recipient with questions about who they themselves are now. Our study provides a nuanced understanding of heart transplant recipients' embodied experiences of self and identity. Insights gained are valuable to educate transplant professionals to develop new supportive interventions both pre- and post-transplant, and to improve the process of informed consent. Ultimately, such insights could be used to enable heart transplant recipients to incorporate the graft optimally over time, easing distress and improving recovery.
在心脏移植受者中,30% 的人报告称移植后存在持续或间歇性的情绪问题,这些问题并非由药物或病理生理变化引起。为此,我们的团队推测,心脏移植引发了一些紧迫的新问题,比如患者如何将移植的心脏融入自我认知,以及这如何影响他们的身份认同。梅洛 - 庞蒂的著作为此项目提供了理论基础,因为它阐释了身体变化如何影响自我,并提供了一个创新框架来探讨心脏移植患者生活中的这些复杂方面。我们采用视觉方法,以视频方式记录了25次半结构化访谈。视觉数据和言语数据在一个迭代过程中同时进行分析。最常见的主题是参与者表示他们的身份认同和身体完整性受到了干扰。此外,参与者报告了与捐赠者的联系,即使移植的心脏被视为入侵者或陌生人。最后,移植受者在描述和猜测他们如何想象捐赠者时非常生动。从陌生人那里接受一个匿名捐赠器官往往会让受者对自己现在是谁产生疑问。我们的研究对心脏移植受者的自我和身份认同的身体体验提供了细致入微的理解。获得的见解对于教育移植专业人员制定新的移植前和移植后支持性干预措施以及改进知情同意过程具有重要价值。最终,这些见解可用于使心脏移植受者随着时间的推移最佳地融入移植器官,减轻痛苦并促进康复。