Hutton Guy, Menne Bettina
Water and Sanitation Program, World Bank, New Delhi, India.
World Health Organization (WHO) Regional Office for Europe, Platz der Vereinten Nationen, Bonn, Germany.
Environ Health Insights. 2014 Nov 3;8:43-52. doi: 10.4137/EHI.S16486. eCollection 2014.
In responding to the health impacts of climate change, economic evidence and tools inform decision makers of the efficiency of alternative health policies and interventions. In a time when sweeping budget cuts are affecting all tiers of government, economic evidence on health protection from climate change spending enables comparison with other public spending.
The review included 53 countries of the World Health Organization (WHO) European Region. Literature was obtained using a Medline and Internet search of key terms in published reports and peer-reviewed literature, and from institutions working on health and climate change. Articles were included if they provided economic estimation of the health impacts of climate change or adaptation measures to protect health from climate change in the WHO European Region. Economic studies are classified under health impact cost, health adaptation cost, and health economic evaluation (comparing both costs and impacts).
A total of 40 relevant studies from Europe were identified, covering the health damage or adaptation costs related to the health effects of climate change and response measures to climate-sensitive diseases. No economic evaluation studies were identified of response measures specific to the impacts of climate change. Existing studies vary in terms of the economic outcomes measured and the methods for evaluation of health benefits. The lack of robust health impact data underlying economic studies significantly affects the availability and precision of economic studies.
Economic evidence in European countries on the costs of and response to climate-sensitive diseases is extremely limited and fragmented. Further studies are urgently needed that examine health impacts and the costs and efficiency of alternative responses to climate-sensitive health conditions, in particular extreme weather events (other than heat) and potential emerging diseases and other conditions threatening Europe.
在应对气候变化对健康的影响时,经济证据和工具可帮助决策者了解替代健康政策和干预措施的效率。在全面削减预算影响各级政府的时期,关于气候变化支出对健康保护作用的经济证据有助于与其他公共支出进行比较。
该综述涵盖了世界卫生组织(WHO)欧洲区域的53个国家。通过对已发表报告和同行评审文献中的关键词进行Medline和互联网搜索,并从致力于健康与气候变化的机构获取文献。如果文章提供了对气候变化对健康的影响或欧洲区域内保护健康免受气候变化影响的适应措施的经济评估,则将其纳入。经济研究分为健康影响成本、健康适应成本和健康经济评估(比较成本和影响)。
共确定了40项来自欧洲的相关研究,涵盖与气候变化对健康的影响以及对气候敏感疾病的应对措施相关的健康损害或适应成本。未发现针对气候变化影响的应对措施的经济评估研究。现有研究在衡量的经济结果和健康效益评估方法方面各不相同。经济研究缺乏可靠的健康影响数据,这严重影响了经济研究的可得性和精确性。
欧洲国家关于气候敏感疾病成本及应对措施的经济证据极为有限且零散。迫切需要进一步开展研究,以考察健康影响以及对气候敏感健康状况(特别是极端天气事件(除高温外)以及潜在的新出现疾病和其他威胁欧洲的状况)的替代应对措施的成本和效率。