Kim Jeong-Hun, Bießmann Felix, Lee Seong-Whan
IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng. 2015 Sep;23(5):867-76. doi: 10.1109/TNSRE.2014.2375879. Epub 2014 Dec 2.
Decoding motor commands from noninvasively measured neural signals has become important in brain-computer interface (BCI) research. Applications of BCI include neurorehabilitation after stroke and control of limb prostheses. Until now, most studies have tested simple movement trajectories in two dimensions by using constant velocity profiles. However, most real-world scenarios require much more complex movement trajectories and velocity profiles. In this study, we decoded motor commands in three dimensions from electroencephalography (EEG) recordings while the subjects either executed or observed/imagined complex upper limb movement trajectories. We compared the accuracy of simple linear methods and nonlinear methods. In line with previous studies our results showed that linear decoders are an efficient and robust method for decoding motor commands. However, while we took the same precautions as previous studies to suppress eye-movement related EEG contamination, we found that subtracting residual electro-oculogram activity from the EEG data resulted in substantially lower motor decoding accuracy for linear decoders. This effect severely limits the transfer of previous results to practical applications in which neural activation is targeted. We observed that nonlinear methods showed no such drop in decoding performance. Our results demonstrate that eye-movement related contamination of brain signals constitutes a severe problem for decoding motor signals from EEG data. These results are important for developing accurate decoders of motor signal from neural signals for use with BCI-based neural prostheses and neurorehabilitation in real-world scenarios.
从无创测量的神经信号中解码运动指令在脑机接口(BCI)研究中变得愈发重要。BCI的应用包括中风后的神经康复以及肢体假肢的控制。到目前为止,大多数研究通过使用匀速轮廓来测试二维的简单运动轨迹。然而,大多数现实场景需要更为复杂的运动轨迹和速度轮廓。在本研究中,我们在受试者执行或观察/想象复杂上肢运动轨迹时,从脑电图(EEG)记录中解码三维运动指令。我们比较了简单线性方法和非线性方法的准确性。与先前研究一致,我们的结果表明线性解码器是解码运动指令的一种有效且稳健的方法。然而,尽管我们采取了与先前研究相同的预防措施来抑制与眼动相关的EEG干扰,但我们发现从EEG数据中减去残余眼电图活动会导致线性解码器的运动解码准确性大幅降低。这种效应严重限制了先前结果向神经激活目标的实际应用的转化。我们观察到非线性方法在解码性能上没有出现这种下降。我们的结果表明,与眼动相关的脑信号干扰是从EEG数据中解码运动信号的一个严重问题。这些结果对于开发用于基于BCI的神经假肢和现实场景中的神经康复的神经信号运动信号精确解码器具有重要意义。