Cohen M S
UCLA Center for Cognitive Neuroscience 760 Westwood Plaza, Suite 17-369 Los Angeles, CA 90095 USA
IEEE Netw. 2009 Nov;2009:1593-1597. doi: 10.1109/ACSSC.2009.5470165.
The windows into brain function given us by the instruments of neuroimaging each are murky and their view is limited. Simultaneous collection of data from multiple modalities offers the potential to overcome the weaknesses of any tool alone. We argue that the combination of electroencephalography (EEG) and functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) offers observations - and hypothesis testing - not possible using either single instrument. Because of their safety profiles and their non-invasive natures, EEG fMRI are among the best available devices for the study of human brain. These methods are complementary. EEG is fast, operating in a time domain comparable to single unit activity, but its localizing power is poor and the field of view is limited. While fMRI has the highest spatial resolution of any noninvasive imaging method and can reveal multiple centers of brain activity implicated in cognitive tasks, it is very slow compared to mental activity and is a poor choice for studying rapidly evolving processes. Here, we address theoretical models of the coupling between EEG and fMRI signals based on cellular physiology and energetics and argue that both tools observe principally synaptic activity. We discuss the technical problems of mutual interference then present several models of brain rhythms for which the joint EEG and fMRI observations provide significant evidence.
神经成像仪器为我们提供的洞察大脑功能的窗口都有些模糊,其视野也很有限。从多个模态同时收集数据有可能克服任何单一工具的弱点。我们认为,脑电图(EEG)和功能磁共振成像(fMRI)的结合能提供单独使用任何一种仪器都无法实现的观察结果及假设检验。由于其安全性和非侵入性,EEG和fMRI是研究人类大脑的最佳可用设备之一。这些方法是互补的。EEG速度快,在与单个神经元活动相当的时间域内运行,但其定位能力较差且视野有限。虽然fMRI具有任何非侵入性成像方法中最高的空间分辨率,并且能够揭示认知任务中涉及的多个大脑活动中心,但与心理活动相比它非常缓慢,对于研究快速演变的过程而言不是一个好选择。在此,我们基于细胞生理学和能量学探讨EEG与fMRI信号之间耦合的理论模型,并认为这两种工具主要观察的是突触活动。我们讨论了相互干扰的技术问题,然后展示了几种脑节律模型,联合EEG和fMRI观察为这些模型提供了重要证据。