Olson KayLoni L, Emery Charles F
From the Departments of Psychology (K.L.O., C.F.E.) and Internal Medicine (C.F.E.), and Institute for Behavioral Medicine Research (C.F.E.), The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio.
Psychosom Med. 2015 Jan;77(1):59-67. doi: 10.1097/PSY.0000000000000127.
Mindfulness training has been incorporated increasingly into weight loss programs to facilitate dietary and physical activity changes. This systematic review of studies using mindfulness-based programs for weight loss evaluated study methodologies with the goal of determining the current evidence in support of mindfulness interventions for weight loss.
Published studies of mindfulness-based interventions for weight loss were identified through systematic review including a comprehensive search of online databases. Studies were reviewed and graded according to methodological strengths and weaknesses.
A total of 19 studies, including 13 randomized controlled trials and 6 observational studies, evaluated the effects of mindfulness-based interventions on weight among individuals attempting weight loss. Twelve of the studies were published in peer-reviewed journals and seven were unpublished dissertations. Among the eight randomized controlled trials published in peer-reviewed journals, six documented significant weight loss among participants in the mindfulness condition, one reported no significant change, and one failed to report body mass index at program completion. None of the studies documented a relationship between changes in mindfulness and weight loss.
Significant weight loss was documented among participants in mindfulness interventions for 13 of the 19 studies identified for review. However, studies do not clarify the degree to which changes in mindfulness are a mechanism responsible for weight loss in mindfulness interventions. Methodological weaknesses and variability across studies limit the strength of the evidence. Further research is needed to document and evaluate the psychological, behavioral, and biological mechanisms involved in the relationship between mindfulness and weight loss.
正念训练已越来越多地被纳入减肥计划中,以促进饮食和身体活动的改变。本项对使用基于正念的计划进行减肥的研究的系统评价,评估了研究方法,目的是确定目前支持正念干预减肥的证据。
通过系统评价确定已发表的基于正念的减肥干预研究,包括对在线数据库的全面检索。根据方法的优缺点对研究进行审查和分级。
共有19项研究,包括13项随机对照试验和6项观察性研究,评估了基于正念的干预措施对减肥个体体重的影响。其中12项研究发表在同行评审期刊上,7项是未发表的论文。在同行评审期刊上发表的8项随机对照试验中,6项记录了正念组参与者显著的体重减轻,1项报告无显著变化,1项未报告项目结束时的体重指数。没有一项研究记录正念变化与体重减轻之间的关系。
在所确定的19项供审查的研究中,有13项研究记录了正念干预参与者的显著体重减轻。然而,研究并未阐明正念变化在多大程度上是正念干预中体重减轻的一个机制。研究方法的弱点和研究之间的变异性限制了证据的强度。需要进一步的研究来记录和评估正念与体重减轻之间关系中涉及的心理、行为和生物学机制。