Jahoda A, Melville C A, Pert C, Cooper S-A, Lynn H, Williams C, Davidson C
Institute of Health and Wellbeing, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK.
Learning Disability Service, NHS Ayrshire and Arran, UK.
J Intellect Disabil Res. 2015 Nov;59(11):1010-21. doi: 10.1111/jir.12175. Epub 2014 Dec 14.
Important work has been carried out adapting cognitive behavioural therapy for people with intellectual disabilities. However, there is a lack of alternative psychological therapies available for people with intellectual disabilities and emotional difficulties. Behavioural activation for depression is less reliant on verbal communication and focuses on increasing purposeful activity and reducing avoidance.
This feasibility study involved the development and piloting of an adapted manual of behavioural activation for people with intellectual disabilities. The intervention consisted of 10-12 sessions and a key adaptation was that the therapist worked with the clients alongside a significant other in their life, either a paid carer or family member. Baseline, post-intervention (3 months after entering the study) and 6-month quantitative follow-up data were obtained. Primary outcome data were gathered, concerning depressive symptoms, participants' levels of activity and general well-being.
Twenty-three adults with intellectual disabilities with symptoms of depression were recruited from specialist health services. In terms of acceptability, the behavioural activation intervention was well received and only two individuals dropped out, with a further two lost to follow-up. The main measures of depression appeared to be sensitive to change. Pre- to post-intervention data showed a significant reduction in self-report of depressive symptoms with a strong effect size (r = 0.78), that was maintained at follow-up (r = 0.86). Positive change was also obtained for informant reports of depressive symptoms from pre- to post-intervention, with a strong effect size (r = 0.7). Once again, this positive change was maintained at follow-up (r = 0.72).
The study suggested that behavioural activation may be a feasible and worthwhile approach to tackling depression in people with intellectual disabilities. However, a randomised controlled trial would be required to establish its effectiveness, with more sensitive measurement of change in activity.
针对智障人士调整认知行为疗法已开展了重要工作。然而,对于有智障和情感困扰的人来说,缺乏其他可用的心理疗法。针对抑郁症的行为激活疗法较少依赖言语交流,侧重于增加有目的的活动并减少回避行为。
这项可行性研究涉及为智障人士开发并试行一本改编的行为激活手册。干预包括10 - 12次疗程,一个关键的调整是治疗师与服务对象以及他们生活中的一位重要他人(付费护理人员或家庭成员)一起工作。获取了基线、干预后(进入研究3个月后)和6个月的定量随访数据。收集了关于抑郁症状、参与者活动水平和总体幸福感的主要结局数据。
从专科健康服务机构招募了23名有抑郁症状的成年智障人士。在可接受性方面,行为激活干预受到好评,只有两人退出,另有两人失访。主要的抑郁测量指标似乎对变化敏感。干预前至干预后的数据显示,抑郁症状的自我报告显著减少,效应量较大(r = 0.78),随访时保持这一效果(r = 0.86)。干预前至干预后,抑郁症状的 informant 报告也有积极变化,效应量较大(r = 0.7)。同样,这种积极变化在随访时保持(r = 0.72)。
该研究表明,行为激活可能是解决智障人士抑郁症的一种可行且有价值的方法。然而,需要进行随机对照试验来确定其有效性,并更敏感地测量活动变化。