Di Giulio Massimo
Early Evolution of Life Laboratory, Institute of Biosciences and Bioresources, CNR, Via P. Castellino, 111, 80131, Naples, Italy,
J Mol Evol. 2015 Feb;80(2):98-101. doi: 10.1007/s00239-014-9662-8. Epub 2014 Dec 23.
The meaning of the term prokaryote is critically analyzed. The conclusion reached is that this term does not have a real biological sense, above all because we are not able to link to this term a specific biological characteristic, i.e. the hypothetical evolutionary stage of the prokaryote would seem to have been unable to result in a completed cell, which could possibly be due to the recapitulation of the fundamental characteristics that might have been common to bacteria and archaea. This would define a biological immaturity of this evolutionary stage because otherwise we would have found traits already clearly defined at this level of cellular evolution. Therefore, the lack of well-defined traits characterising the prokaryote would seem to imply an evolutionary stage still in rapid evolution, i.e. with a tempo and a mode of evolution typical of a progenote. This in turn would seem to imply that the last universal common ancestor (LUCA) has been a progenote at least when the domains of life are only two-the bacterial and archaeal domains-because, in this case, the LUCA's node should coincide with that of prokaryote on the tree of life. Instead, if the root of the tree of life would be placed in the bacterial domain or in the archaeal one, we might again, very likely, have a LUCA with a character of progenote being, under these conditions, the LUCA a prokaryote-like organism.
对“原核生物”这一术语的含义进行了批判性分析。得出的结论是,这个术语没有真正的生物学意义,首先是因为我们无法将特定的生物学特征与该术语联系起来,也就是说,原核生物假设的进化阶段似乎无法产生一个完整的细胞,这可能是由于细菌和古菌可能共有的基本特征的重演。这将定义这个进化阶段的生物学不成熟性,因为否则我们会在细胞进化的这个层面上发现已经明确界定的特征。因此,缺乏明确界定的特征来表征原核生物似乎意味着一个仍在快速进化的进化阶段,即具有原祖典型的进化速度和模式。这反过来似乎意味着,至少当生命域只有两个——细菌域和古菌域时,最后一个普遍共同祖先(LUCA)是一个原祖,因为在这种情况下,LUCA的节点应该与生命树上原核生物的节点重合。相反,如果生命树的根置于细菌域或古菌域,我们很可能再次得到一个具有原祖特征的LUCA,在这些条件下,LUCA是一种类似原核生物的生物体。