Crockford Catherine, Wittig Roman M, Zuberbühler Klaus
Department of Primatology, Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, Deutscher Platz 6, 04103, Leipzig, Germany,
Anim Cogn. 2015 May;18(3):581-91. doi: 10.1007/s10071-014-0827-z. Epub 2014 Dec 24.
A vital step in the evolution of language is likely to have been when signalers explicitly intended to direct recipients' attention to external objects with the use of referential signals. Although animal signals can direct the attention of others to external events, such as in monkey predator alarm calls, there is little evidence that this is the result of an intention to inform the recipient. Two recent studies, however, indicate that the production of chimpanzee quiet alarm calls, given to snakes, complies with some standard behavioral markers of intentional signaling, such as gaze alternation. But it is currently unknown whether the calls alone direct receivers' attention to the threat. To address this, we carried out a playback experiment with free-ranging chimpanzees in Budongo Forest, Uganda, using a within-subjects design. From a hidden speaker, we broadcast either quiet alarm 'hoos' ('alert hoos') or acoustically distinguishable hoos produced while resting ('rest hoos') and found a significant increase in search behavior after 'alert' compared with 'rest' hoos, with subjects monitoring either the call provider or the area near the call provider. In sum, chimpanzee 'alert hoos' represent a plausible case of an intentionally produced animal vocalization (other studies) that refers recipients to signalers and/or to an external event (this study).
语言进化过程中的一个关键步骤可能是信号发出者开始明确意图,通过使用指示性信号将接收者的注意力引向外部物体。虽然动物信号可以将其他动物的注意力引向外部事件,比如猴子发出的捕食者警报叫声,但几乎没有证据表明这是出于告知接收者的意图。然而,最近的两项研究表明,黑猩猩针对蛇发出的安静警报叫声符合一些有意信号的标准行为特征,比如目光交替。但目前尚不清楚这些叫声本身是否能将接收者的注意力引向威胁。为了解决这个问题,我们在乌干达布东戈森林对自由放养的黑猩猩进行了一项回放实验,采用了被试内设计。我们从一个隐藏的扬声器播放安静的警报“呼”声(“警戒呼”声)或休息时发出的声学上可区分的“呼”声(“休息呼”声),发现与“休息呼”声相比,播放“警戒呼”声后,黑猩猩的搜索行为显著增加,它们会监视发出叫声的个体或该个体附近的区域。总之,黑猩猩的“警戒呼”声代表了一种可能是有意发出的动物叫声(其他研究),它能将接收者的注意力引向信号发出者和/或一个外部事件(本研究)。