Siemens Waldemar, Gaertner Jan, Becker Gerhild
University Medical Center, Department of Palliative Care , Freiburg , Germany
Expert Opin Pharmacother. 2015 Mar;16(4):515-32. doi: 10.1517/14656566.2015.995625. Epub 2014 Dec 24.
Opioid-induced constipation (OIC) is one of the most frequent and burdening adverse events (AE) of opioid therapy. This systematic review aimed to evaluate efficacy and safety of drugs in randomized controlled trials (RCTs) with adult OIC patients.
Efficacy assessment focused on objective outcome measures (OOMs): bowel movement (BM) frequency, BM within 4 h and time to first BM. Twenty-one studies examining seven drugs were identified. Methylnaltrexone showed improvements in all three OOMs. RCTs in naloxone and alvimopan tended to be effective for BM frequency measures. Naloxegol (≥ 12.5 mg) improved all OOMs. Though effectiveness of lubiprostone was demonstrated for all OOMs, group differences were small to moderate. CB-5945 and prucalopride tended to increase BM frequency, especially for 0.1 mg twice daily and 4 mg daily, respectively. Besides nausea and diarrhea, abdominal pain was the most frequent AE for all drugs (risk ratio, range: 1.52 - 5.06) except for alvimopan. Treatment-related serious AEs were slightly higher for alvimopan (cardiac events) and prucalopride (severe abdominal pain, headache). Pain scores for placebo and intervention groups were similar for all drugs.
Finding a consensus definition and inclusion criteria for OIC plus a rational balance between efficacy and AEs of drugs remain future challenges.
阿片类药物引起的便秘(OIC)是阿片类药物治疗中最常见且负担较重的不良事件之一。本系统评价旨在评估针对成年OIC患者的随机对照试验(RCT)中药物的疗效和安全性。
疗效评估聚焦于客观结局指标(OOMs):排便频率、4小时内排便情况及首次排便时间。共识别出21项研究7种药物。甲基纳曲酮在所有三项OOMs上均有改善。纳洛酮和阿维莫潘的RCT在排便频率测量方面往往有效。纳洛西醇(≥12.5毫克)改善了所有OOMs。尽管鲁比前列酮对所有OOMs的有效性得到了证实,但组间差异为小到中度。CB - 5945和普芦卡必利倾向于增加排便频率,分别尤其对于每日两次0.1毫克和每日4毫克。除阿维莫潘外,腹痛是所有药物最常见的不良事件(风险比,范围:1.52 - 5.06)。阿维莫潘(心脏事件)和普芦卡必利(严重腹痛、头痛)的治疗相关严重不良事件略高。所有药物的安慰剂组和干预组的疼痛评分相似。
为OIC找到共识定义和纳入标准以及在药物疗效和不良事件之间实现合理平衡仍是未来的挑战。