Edwards Kelly J, Duff Jed, Walker Kim
St Vincent's Private Hospital, Sydney, NSW, Australia, 2. University of Tasmania, Hobart, TAS, Australia.
Contemp Nurse. 2014;49:122-36. doi: 10.5172/conu.2014.49.122.
'Patient experience' is both recognised and solicited as a means of assessing healthcare delivery and a method for gauging patient centredness. Research comparing healthcare recipient and provider perceptions regarding the same episode of care is lacking.
To identify what mattered to a patient and family member (healthcare recipients) during the patient's hospital experience and to examine the healthcare provider's awareness of what mattered.
A qualitative descriptive investigation was undertaken using semi-structured interviews designed to compare multiple perceptions of one patient's hospital experience. Interviews were undertaken with the patient, family member, and healthcare providers. A definition of hospital experience was sought from each participant. Additional phrases as presented by the patient and family member were coded and grouped into categories and then salient themes. Phrases as presented by the healthcare providers were coded, and then allocated to the previously identified themes.
One patient, his wife and seven healthcare providers (doctors (2), registered nurses (4) and a patient care orderly (1)) were interviewed. Definitions of 'hospital experience' differ between participants. Recipients include pre and post hospital admission periods, whereas providers limit hospital experience to admission. Three salient themes emerged from recipient data suggesting; medication management, physical comfort and emotional security are what mattered to the recipients. Awareness was dependent upon theme and differed between the providers.
Hospital experience as a term is poorly defined, and definitions differ between recipients and providers of care. Healthcare providers are not always aware of what matters to the patient and family during their hospital admission.
“患者体验”作为评估医疗服务提供情况和衡量以患者为中心程度的一种手段,已得到认可并被广泛应用。然而,目前缺乏关于医疗服务接受者和提供者对同一护理过程看法的比较研究。
确定在患者住院期间对患者及其家属(医疗服务接受者)而言重要的因素,并考察医疗服务提供者对这些重要因素的认知情况。
采用定性描述性调查,通过半结构化访谈来比较对一名患者住院经历的多种看法。访谈对象包括患者、家属和医疗服务提供者。向每位参与者询问对住院经历的定义。对患者和家属提出的其他表述进行编码,并归类分组形成突出主题。对医疗服务提供者提出的表述进行编码,然后归入先前确定的主题。
对一名患者、其妻子以及七名医疗服务提供者(2名医生、4名注册护士和1名护工)进行了访谈。不同参与者对“住院经历”的定义存在差异。接受者认为住院经历包括入院前和入院后阶段,而提供者则将住院经历局限于住院期间。从接受者的数据中浮现出三个突出主题,即药物管理、身体舒适度和情绪安全感对接受者而言至关重要。医疗服务提供者的认知因主题而异。
“住院经历”这一术语定义不明确,护理接受者和提供者的定义存在差异。医疗服务提供者并不总是了解患者及其家属在住院期间认为重要的因素。