Moftakhar Parham, Cooke Daniel L, Fullerton Heather J, Ko Nerissa U, Amans Matthew R, Narvid Jared A, Dowd Christopher F, Higashida Randall T, Halbach Van V, Hetts Steven W
Departments of 1 Radiology and Biomedical Imaging.
J Neurosurg Pediatr. 2015 Mar;15(3):282-90. doi: 10.3171/2014.9.PEDS14313. Epub 2015 Jan 2.
Although the development and prevalence of cerebral vasospasm (CV) has been extensively investigated in adults, little data exist on the development of CV in children. The authors hypothesized that even though children have highly vasoreactive arteries, because of a robust cerebral collateral blood flow, they rarely develop symptomatic CV.
The authors retrospectively reviewed their university hospital's neurointerventional database for children (that is, patients ≤ 18 years) who were examined or treated for aneurysmal or traumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) during the period 1990-2013. Images from digital subtraction angiography (DSA) were analyzed for the extent of CV and collateralization of the cerebral circulation. Results from transcranial Doppler (TCD) ultrasonography were correlated with those from DSA. Cerebral vasospasm on TCD ultrasonography was defined according to criteria developed for adults. Clinical outcomes of CV were assessed with the pediatric modified Rankin Scale (mRS).
Among 37 children (21 boys and 16 girls ranging in age from 8 months to 18 years) showing symptoms of an aneurysmal SAH (comprising 32 aneurysms and 5 traumatic pseudoaneurysms), 17 (46%) had CV confirmed by DSA; CV was mild in 21% of these children, moderate in 50%, and severe in 29%. Only 3 children exhibited symptomatic CV, all of whom had poor collateralization of cerebral vessels. Among the 14 asymptomatic children, 10 (71%) showed some degree of vessel collateralization. Among 16 children for whom TCD data were available that could be correlated with the DSA findings, 13 (81%) had CV according to TCD criteria. The sensitivity and specificity of TCD ultrasonography for diagnosing CV were 95% and 59%, respectively. The time to CV onset detected by TCD ultrasonography was 5 ± 3 days (range 2-10 days). Twenty-five (68%) of the children had good long-term outcomes (that is, had mRS scores of 0-2).
Children have a relatively high incidence of angiographically detectable, moderate-to-severe CV. Children rarely develop symptomatic CV and have good long-term outcomes, perhaps due to robust cerebral collateral blood flow. Criteria developed for detecting CV with TCD ultrasonography in adults overestimate the prevalence of CV in children. Larger studies are needed to define TCD ultrasonography-based CV criteria for children.
尽管成人脑血管痉挛(CV)的发生发展及患病率已得到广泛研究,但关于儿童CV发生情况的数据却很少。作者推测,尽管儿童动脉血管反应性高,但由于强大的脑侧支血流,他们很少发生有症状的CV。
作者回顾性分析了他们大学医院1990年至2013年期间对患有动脉瘤性或创伤性蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)的儿童(即年龄≤18岁的患者)进行检查或治疗的神经介入数据库。分析数字减影血管造影(DSA)图像以确定CV的程度和脑循环的侧支循环情况。经颅多普勒(TCD)超声检查结果与DSA结果相关联。TCD超声检查中的脑血管痉挛根据为成人制定的标准进行定义。CV的临床结局采用儿科改良Rankin量表(mRS)进行评估。
在37名出现动脉瘤性SAH症状的儿童(21名男孩和16名女孩,年龄从8个月至18岁)中,有32个动脉瘤和5个创伤性假性动脉瘤,17名(46%)经DSA证实患有CV;其中21%的儿童CV为轻度,50%为中度,29%为重度。只有3名儿童出现有症状的CV,他们的脑血管侧支循环均较差。在14名无症状儿童中,10名(71%)显示出一定程度的血管侧支循环。在16名有可与DSA结果相关联的TCD数据的儿童中,根据TCD标准,13名(81%)患有CV。TCD超声检查诊断CV的敏感性和特异性分别为95%和59%。TCD超声检查检测到CV发作的时间为5±3天(范围2 - 10天)。25名(68%)儿童有良好的长期结局(即mRS评分为0 - 2)。
儿童血管造影可检测到的中重度CV发生率相对较高。儿童很少发生有症状的CV且长期结局良好,这可能归因于强大的脑侧支血流。为成人制定的用TCD超声检查检测CV的标准高估了儿童CV的患病率。需要开展更大规模的研究来确定基于TCD超声检查的儿童CV标准。