Altin Carolina, Kvist Lindholm Sofia, Wejdmark Mats, Lättman-Masch Robert, Boldemann Cecilia
Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
University of Linköping, Linköping, Sweden Centre for Epidemiology and Community Medicine, Stockholm County Council, Stockholm, Sweden
Health Promot Pract. 2015 Jul;16(4):583-91. doi: 10.1177/1524839914566273. Epub 2015 Jan 14.
Redesigning outdoor preschool environment may favorably affect multiple factors relevant to health and reach many children. Cross-sectional studies in various landscapes at different latitudes have explored the characteristics of preschool outdoor environment considering the play potential triggering combined physical activity and sun-protective behavior due to space, vegetation, and topography. Criteria were pinpointed to upgrade preschool outdoor environment for multiple health outcomes to be applied in local government in charge of public preschools. Purposeful land use policies and administrative management of outdoor land use may serve to monitor the quality of preschool outdoor environments (upgrading and planning). This study evaluates the process of implementing routines for upgrading outdoor preschool environments in a medium-sized municipality, Sweden, 2008-2011, using qualitative and quantitative analysis. Recorded written material (logs and protocols) related to the project was processed using thematic analysis. Quantitative data (m(2) flat/multileveled, overgrown/naked surface, and fraction of free visible sky) were analyzed to assess the impact of implementation (surface, topography, greenery integrated in play). The preschool outdoor environments were upgraded accordingly. The quality of implementation was assessed using the theory of policy streams approach. Though long-term impact remains to be confirmed the process seems to have changed work routines in the interior management for purposeful upgrading of preschool outdoor environments. The aptitude and applicability of inexpensive methods for assessing, selecting, and upgrading preschool land at various latitudes, climates, and outdoor play policies (including gender aspects and staff policies) should be further discussed, as well as the compilation of data for monitoring and evaluation.
重新设计户外幼儿园环境可能会对多个与健康相关的因素产生积极影响,并惠及许多儿童。在不同纬度的各种景观中进行的横断面研究,探讨了幼儿园户外环境的特征,考虑到空间、植被和地形等因素引发的身体活动和防晒行为的游戏潜力。确定了相关标准,以改善幼儿园户外环境,实现多种健康效益,供负责公立幼儿园的地方政府采用。有针对性的土地使用政策和户外土地使用行政管理可用于监测幼儿园户外环境的质量(改善和规划)。本研究采用定性和定量分析方法,评估了瑞典一个中等规模城市在2008 - 2011年期间改善幼儿园户外环境的实施过程。使用主题分析法对与该项目相关的记录书面材料(日志和协议)进行了处理。分析了定量数据(平面/多层面积、植被茂盛/光秃表面以及可见天空的比例),以评估实施的影响(表面、地形、融入游戏的绿化)。幼儿园户外环境据此得到了改善。使用政策流理论方法评估了实施质量。尽管长期影响仍有待确认,但该过程似乎已经改变了内部管理中的工作流程,以有目的地改善幼儿园户外环境。应进一步讨论在不同纬度、气候和户外游戏政策(包括性别方面和员工政策)下,评估、选择和改善幼儿园用地的低成本方法的适用性和实用性,以及用于监测和评估的数据汇编。