Solias A, Skapinakis P, Degleris N, Pantoleon M, Katirtzoglou E, Politis A
1st Department of Psychiatry, University of Athens, Medical School, Eginition Hospital, Athens.
Department of Psychiatry, School of Medicine, University of Ioannina, Ioannina.
Psychiatriki. 2014 Oct-Dec;25(4):245-56.
For the last 38 years, Mini Mental State Examination (MMSE) has been widely used as a dementia screening measure in everyday clinical practice as well as in both cohort and cross-sectional studies. Its validity and reliability for the Greek population has explicitly been documented. However, the effect of age and education on the subject's performance makes it necessary to reckon them in the estimation of the "cutoff score". The purpose of this study is to estimate the prevalence of dementia in Greek population and determine the "cutoff score" by age and education-corrected norms. Cross sectional study of 630 patients older than 55 years, who live independently in Ilion and Helioupolis Municipalities was conducted, 27.3% of the subjects tested in the study were diagnosed with memory disorder according to their MMSE scores and the validation for the Greek population. The effect of age and education to the subjects' performance was statistically significant (p=.000). The use of standard "cutoff score" was not proved to be useful for the personalized interpretation of the results, as documented by the fact that older individuals with lower education had a poorer performance relatively to younger, highly educated subjects. Comparatively to the group age of 55-60 years, the odds ratio after the age of 75 years varies from 2.58 to 4.91. Regarding the variable factor of education, the odds ratio for the first degree education graduates decreases from 1.43 to 3.19 for the third degree education graduates in comparison with the group of illiterates. In conclusion, the use of the "cutoff score" algorithm and the simultaneous estimation of age and education effect on MMSE score may prove useful for the proper evaluation of MMSE performance. According to the age and education of examine candidates in the community and the primary care, we propose the use of the 25th percentile as a more useful cutoff score in order to decrease the false positive results.
在过去的38年里,简易精神状态检查表(MMSE)在日常临床实践以及队列研究和横断面研究中都被广泛用作痴呆筛查工具。其在希腊人群中的有效性和可靠性已得到明确记录。然而,年龄和教育程度对受试者表现的影响使得在估计“临界值”时必须将它们考虑在内。本研究的目的是估计希腊人群中痴呆的患病率,并通过年龄和教育程度校正后的规范确定“临界值”。对居住在伊利翁和赫利奥波利斯市、年龄超过55岁且独立生活的630名患者进行了横断面研究,根据他们的MMSE分数和希腊人群的验证结果,27.3%的研究受试者被诊断患有记忆障碍。年龄和教育程度对受试者表现的影响具有统计学意义(p = 0.000)。标准“临界值”的使用被证明对结果的个性化解释并无帮助,事实证明,教育程度较低的老年人相对于年轻、受过高等教育的受试者表现较差。与55 - 60岁年龄组相比,75岁以后的优势比在2.58至4.91之间变化。关于教育程度这一可变因素,与文盲组相比,小学教育毕业生的优势比从1.43降至高等教育毕业生的3.19。总之,使用“临界值”算法以及同时估计年龄和教育程度对MMSE分数的影响可能对正确评估MMSE表现有用。根据社区和初级保健中候选检查对象的年龄和教育程度,我们建议使用第25百分位数作为更有用的临界值,以减少假阳性结果。