Silva Cristina, Ramalho Célia, Luz Isabel, Monteiro Joaquim, Fresco Paula
SerFarma, Ltd, Coimbra, Portugal.
Int J Clin Pharm. 2015 Apr;37(2):327-34. doi: 10.1007/s11096-014-0063-2. Epub 2015 Jan 31.
An aging population and the increasing prevalence of chronic diseases have led to the increased use of medicines. Portugal is one of the European countries where more medicines are consumed and the associated expense is higher. Medicines are associated with enormous health benefits but also with the potential to cause illness and death. A drug related problem (DRP) is an "an event or circumstance involving drug therapy that actually or potentially interferes with desired health outcomes". In the U.S., they represent the 4th-6th leading cause of death and have an estimated cost of 130 billion dollars. Moreover, many of these DRP can be avoided. Elderly are at increased risk of DRP due to multiple factors: pluripathology and consequent polypharmacy, complex dosing regimens, pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic and functional/cognitive changes. Therefore, this population would be the one who would benefit most from the prevention, detection and control of DRP. The role of the pharmacist as an integral element of health care has been recognized by various international and European organizations. Providing pharmaceutical care as a patient-centered activity, focusing on their needs related to pharmacotherapy, contributes to guarantee that drug expenditure is a good investment, with benefits that outweigh potential risks.
To evaluate the need for pharmaceutical care implementation in institutionalized, polymedicated elderly.
Descriptive observational cross-sectional study carried out in six Portuguese nursing homes, selected by convenience, in November-December 2013. Each institution selected up to six patients, according to the following inclusion criteria: age ≥65 years, number of medications ≥5 and ability to respond to an interview. All participants signed an informed consent form. Pharmacists carried out a structured interview with each patient and consulted patient medical records to gather demographic data and information on health problems and medications used. To identify DRP, official drug information sources were consulted, and the STOPP and START tool was used. The ATC, the ICD-10 and the PCNE Classification V 6.2 classification systems were used for medicines, health problems and DRP classifications, respectively. For each medicine used, the cheapest equivalent available was also identified.
The sample included 31 elderly (64.52 % female, mean age 81.65 ± 6.86). On average, subjects presented a mean of 7.94 ± 2.76 health problems with diseases of the circulatory system being the most common. The sample used a median of ten medicines per patient. Those medicines working in the cardiovascular, nervous and digestive systems were the most frequently used (29.75, 29.43 and 19.30 %, respectively). A total of 484 DRP (median: 15 DRP/patient) was found. The most common DRP were Adverse Drug Event, non-allergic (49.51 %), Drug treatment more costly than necessary (19.11 %), Effect of drug treatment not optimal (14.82 %) and Unnecessary drug treatment (6.16 %). The most cost-effective proposal, would lead to a saving of
These results reinforce the need for the implementation of pharmaceutical care services to institutionalized elderly, necessary to improve medicines efficacy and safety, better clinical outcomes and cost reduction.
人口老龄化和慢性病患病率的上升导致药品使用增加。葡萄牙是欧洲药品消费较多且相关费用较高的国家之一。药品带来巨大的健康益处,但也有导致疾病和死亡的可能性。药物相关问题(DRP)是“涉及药物治疗的一个事件或情况,实际或潜在地干扰了期望的健康结果”。在美国,它们是第四至第六大主要死因,估计成本为1300亿美元。此外,许多此类药物相关问题是可以避免的。由于多种因素,老年人发生药物相关问题的风险增加:多种病理状况及随之而来的多药联用、复杂的给药方案、药代动力学/药效学以及功能/认知变化。因此,这一人群将从药物相关问题的预防、检测和控制中获益最大。药剂师作为医疗保健不可或缺的组成部分的作用已得到各种国际和欧洲组织的认可。提供以患者为中心的药学服务,关注他们与药物治疗相关的需求,有助于确保药物支出是一项明智的投资,其益处超过潜在风险。
评估在入住养老院、使用多种药物的老年人中实施药学服务的必要性。
2013年11月至12月,在葡萄牙六家养老院开展描述性观察性横断面研究,采用方便抽样法。每家机构根据以下纳入标准选择最多六名患者:年龄≥65岁、用药数量≥5种且有能力回应访谈。所有参与者均签署知情同意书。药剂师对每位患者进行结构化访谈,并查阅患者病历以收集人口统计学数据以及健康问题和所用药物的信息。为识别药物相关问题,查阅官方药物信息来源,并使用STOPP和START工具。分别使用解剖学治疗学及化学分类系统(ATC)、国际疾病分类第十版(ICD - 10)和初级保健电子网络分类系统(PCNE分类V 6.2)对药物、健康问题和药物相关问题进行分类。对于每种使用的药物,还确定了最便宜的等效可用药物。
样本包括31名老年人(女性占64.52%,平均年龄81.65±6.86岁)。平均而言,受试者有7.94±2.76个健康问题,循环系统疾病最为常见。样本中每位患者使用的药物中位数为十种。作用于心血管、神经和消化系统的药物使用最为频繁(分别为29.75%、29.43%和19.30%)。共发现484个药物相关问题(中位数:每位患者15个药物相关问题)。最常见的药物相关问题是不良药物事件,非过敏性(49.51%)、药物治疗费用高于必要水平(19.11%)、药物治疗效果不佳(14.82%)和不必要的药物治疗(6.16%)。最具成本效益的建议将使研究样本每年节省<3950欧元。
这些结果强化了对入住养老院的老年人实施药学服务的必要性,这对于提高药物疗效和安全性、改善临床结局以及降低成本是必要的。