Jamal Farah, Bonell Chris, Harden Angela, Lorenc Theo
Institute for Health and Human Development, UH250, Stratford Campus, University of East London, Water Lane, London, E15 4LZ, UK.
UCL Institute of Education, University College London, London, WC1H 0AL, UK.
Sociol Health Illn. 2015 Jun;37(5):731-44. doi: 10.1111/1467-9566.12231. Epub 2015 Feb 6.
This exploratory study adopts a socio-ecological approach to examine the context of school bullying. It asks: (1) what are students' accounts of bullying practices?; (2) how are these enabled and constrained by the school-environment?; (3) how is gender implicated? Qualitative data were collected from girls in two schools in London via focus groups (one in each school; students aged 12-15) and seven semi-structured interviews (in one school; students aged 16-18); and from school policy documents. Our interpretation of girls' accounts, informed by Giddens' structuration theory, suggests that bullying practices were spatially patterned in the schools and often characterised by the regulation of girls' sexuality and sexual-harassment. Repeated acts of aggression were fluid with regard to the bully and victim role, challenging the dominant view of bullying as characterised by consistent disparities in power between individuals. Schools structured bullying behaviour via policies and practices that ignored these forms of abuse and which focused on and may have been complicit in the making of stable 'bully' and 'victim' roles, thus indirectly contributing to the reproduction of unhealthy relationships between students. In terms of gender, traditional gendered and sexual discourses appear to structure the identities of the schools and girls in our study.
这项探索性研究采用社会生态方法来审视校园欺凌的背景。它提出了以下问题:(1)学生对欺凌行为的描述是怎样的?(2)学校环境如何促成和限制这些行为?(3)性别因素是如何体现的?通过焦点小组(两所伦敦学校各一个;学生年龄在12至15岁之间)和七次半结构化访谈(在其中一所学校;学生年龄在16至18岁之间),以及学校政策文件,收集了来自两所伦敦学校女生的定性数据。我们依据吉登斯的结构化理论对女生的描述进行解读,结果表明,欺凌行为在学校里呈现出空间分布模式,且往往以对女生性行为和性骚扰的管控为特征。就欺凌者和受害者角色而言,反复出现的攻击行为具有流动性,这挑战了将欺凌主要视为个体间权力持续不平等的主流观点。学校通过政策和做法构建了欺凌行为,这些政策和做法忽视了这些虐待形式,专注于并可能助长了稳定的“欺凌者”和“受害者”角色的形成,从而间接地促使学生间不健康关系的延续。在性别方面,传统的性别和性话语似乎构建了我们研究中学校和女生的身份认同。