Banov C H
Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston.
J Int Med Res. 1989 Mar-Apr;17(2):150-6. doi: 10.1177/030006058901700206.
This 1 week study compared the efficacy of once daily administration of 10 mg loratadine with 120 mg terfenadine in out-patients with seasonal allergic rhinitis. It focussed on the efficacy of treatment at the end of the 24 h period following a daily dose. The study was designed as a double-blind, randomized, parallel-group trial, and 41 patients were enrolled and evaluated for efficacy. Patients took an initial dose at the study site and returned on days 2 and 8. At day 2 (24 h after the initial dose), according to the physician's evaluation 57% of loratadine-treated patients had a good or excellent response, compared to 50% of those given terfenadine. At day 8, 24 h after the final dose, 71% of the loratadine-treated patients and 35% of the terfenadine-treated patients had a good or excellent response (P = 0.03). At days 2 and 8, reductions in mean symptom scores measured 22, 23 and 24 h after the initial and final doses showed an indication of being greater with loratadine than with terfenadine (nonsignificant due to small sample size). The incidence of sedation was similar in both groups. It is concluded that 10 mg loratadine, administered once daily, controls the symptoms of rhinitis more effectively than 120 mg terfenadine given once daily in the last few hours of the 24 h dosing period.
这项为期1周的研究比较了每日一次服用10毫克氯雷他定与120毫克特非那定对季节性变应性鼻炎门诊患者的疗效。该研究聚焦于每日一剂药物后24小时末的治疗效果。研究设计为双盲、随机、平行组试验,共纳入41例患者并评估疗效。患者在研究地点服用初始剂量药物,并在第2天和第8天返回。在第2天(初始剂量后24小时),根据医生评估,氯雷他定治疗组57%的患者有良好或极佳反应,而特非那定治疗组为50%。在第8天,即最后一剂药物后24小时,氯雷他定治疗组71%的患者有良好或极佳反应,特非那定治疗组为35%(P = 0.03)。在第2天和第8天,初始剂量和最后一剂药物后22、23和24小时测量的平均症状评分降低显示,氯雷他定组的降低幅度有大于特非那定组的趋势(由于样本量小无统计学意义)。两组的镇静发生率相似。结论是,每日一次服用10毫克氯雷他定在24小时给药期的最后几小时比每日一次服用120毫克特非那定能更有效地控制鼻炎症状。