King Wade, Ahmed Shihab U, Baisden Jamie, Patel Nileshkumar, Kennedy David J, Duszynski Belinda, MacVicar John
Pendlebury Pain Management, Lingard Hospital, Merewether, New South Wales, Australia.
Pain Med. 2015 Feb;16(2):257-65. doi: 10.1111/pme.12630.
To assess the evidence on the validity of sacral lateral branch blocks and the effectiveness of sacral lateral branch thermal radiofrequency neurotomy in managing sacroiliac complex pain.
Systematic review with comprehensive analysis of all published data.
Six reviewers searched the literature on sacral lateral branch interventions. Each assessed the methodologies of studies found and the quality of the evidence presented.
The outcomes assessed were diagnostic validity and effectiveness of treatment for sacroiliac complex pain. The evidence found was appraised in accordance with the Grades of Recommendation, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) system of evaluating scientific evidence.
The searches yielded two primary publications on sacral lateral branch blocks and 15 studies of the effectiveness of sacral lateral branch thermal radiofrequency neurotomy. One study showed multisite, multidepth sacral lateral branch blocks can anesthetize the posterior sacroiliac ligaments. Therapeutic studies show sacral lateral branch thermal radiofrequency neurotomy can relieve sacroiliac complex pain to some extent. The evidence of the validity of these blocks and the effectiveness of this treatment were rated as moderate in accordance with the GRADE system.
The literature on sacral lateral branch interventions is sparse. One study demonstrates the face validity of multisite, multidepth sacral lateral branch blocks for diagnosis of posterior sacroiliac complex pain. Some evidence of moderate quality exists on therapeutic procedures, but it is insufficient to determine the indications and effectiveness of sacral lateral branch thermal radiofrequency neurotomy, and more research is required.
评估骶外侧支阻滞的有效性以及骶外侧支热凝射频神经切断术治疗骶髂关节复合体疼痛的疗效证据。
对所有已发表数据进行综合分析的系统评价。
六位研究者检索了关于骶外侧支干预的文献。每位研究者评估所发现研究的方法及所呈现证据的质量。
评估的观察指标为骶髂关节复合体疼痛治疗的诊断有效性和疗效。根据推荐分级、评估、制定与评价(GRADE)科学证据评估系统对所发现的证据进行评价。
检索得到两篇关于骶外侧支阻滞的主要文献以及15项关于骶外侧支热凝射频神经切断术疗效的研究。一项研究表明多部位、多深度的骶外侧支阻滞可麻醉骶髂后韧带。治疗性研究表明骶外侧支热凝射频神经切断术可在一定程度上缓解骶髂关节复合体疼痛。根据GRADE系统,这些阻滞的有效性和该治疗方法的疗效证据被评为中等质量。
关于骶外侧支干预的文献较少。一项研究证实多部位、多深度的骶外侧支阻滞对诊断骶髂后复合体疼痛具有表面效度。治疗方法方面存在一些中等质量的证据,但不足以确定骶外侧支热凝射频神经切断术的适应证和疗效,需要更多研究。