Riggs Damien W
School of Social and Policy Studies, Flinders University, GPO Box 2100, Adelaide South, Australia, 5001.
J Med Humanit. 2016 Sep;37(3):313-25. doi: 10.1007/s10912-015-9330-z.
This paper reports on a rhetorical analysis of interviews with fifteen white Australian citizens who had undertaken offshore commercial surrogacy in India. Extending previous research, the findings suggest that genetic relatedness was valorized, and surrogacy constructed as a less tenuous route to family formation. The paper concludes with a discussion of the need for further research on 1) how the contentious nature of offshore commercial surrogacy may prevent full consideration of its ethical implications, 2) the differing belief systems between India and Australia in terms of children as alienable objects, and 3) ongoing consideration of how and when genetic-relatedness is made to matter.
本文报道了对15名在印度进行海外商业代孕的澳大利亚白人公民的访谈的修辞分析。与之前的研究相比,研究结果表明,基因关联性受到重视,代孕被构建为一种不那么脆弱的组建家庭的途径。本文最后讨论了进一步研究的必要性:1)海外商业代孕的争议性如何可能妨碍对其伦理影响的充分考虑;2)印度和澳大利亚在儿童作为可转让对象方面不同的信仰体系;3)持续思考基因关联性如何以及何时变得重要。