Hendren Elizabeth, Gill Jagbir, Landsberg David, Dong Jianghu, Rose Caren, Gill John S
1 Division of Nephrology, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada. 2 Center for Health Evaluation and Outcomes Sciences, Vancouver, BC, Canada. 3 Tufts-New England Medical Center, Boston, MA.
Transplantation. 2015 Sep;99(9):1894-9. doi: 10.1097/TP.0000000000000533.
Participation of compatible living donors and recipients in kidney paired donation (KPD) could double the number of KPD transplants. We determined the willingness of previous directed donors and their recipients to participate in KPD and identified the association of various factors, including financial incentives, with willingness to participate.
Survey of previous directed living kidney donors and their recipients in a single Canadian center between 2001 and 2009.
Among 207 of 222 eligible living donors contacted, 86 (42%) completed the anonymous survey: 93% (78/86) of donors indicated willingness to participate in KPD if this option had been provided at the time of donation. An increased willingness to participate was reported among the majority of respondents if reimbursements for lost wages and travel expenses were provided; however, cash payments between $5 000 and $50 000 had little impact on willingness. Willingness was also increased with an advantage to the recipient (younger donor or better human leukocyte antigen match), whereas delays beyond 3 months and donor travel were associated with reduced willingness to participate. Among 38 recipients approached during routine clinical follow-up visits over a 3-month period, 100% completed the survey, and 36 of 38 (92%) reported they would have been willing to participate in KPD.
Over 90% of directed donors and recipients were willing to participate in KPD. Reimbursement for the costs of participation and improved efficiency of KPD (i.e., eliminating travel and reducing transplant times), but not cash payments, may increase participation of compatible donors and recipients in KPD.
配对的活体供者和受者参与肾脏配对捐赠(KPD)可使KPD移植数量翻倍。我们确定了既往指定供者及其受者参与KPD的意愿,并确定了包括经济激励在内的各种因素与参与意愿之间的关联。
对2001年至2009年期间加拿大一个中心的既往指定活体肾脏供者及其受者进行调查。
在联系的222名符合条件的活体供者中,有207名(86名,42%)完成了匿名调查:93%(78/86)的供者表示,如果在捐赠时提供此选项,他们愿意参与KPD。如果提供误工和差旅费报销,大多数受访者表示参与意愿增加;然而,5000美元至50000美元的现金支付对意愿影响不大。受者优势(供者年轻或人类白细胞抗原匹配更好)也会增加意愿,而超过3个月的延迟和供者出行与参与意愿降低有关。在为期3个月的常规临床随访中接触的38名受者中,100%完成了调查,38名中有36名(92%)报告他们愿意参与KPD。
超过90%的指定供者和受者愿意参与KPD。参与费用的报销和KPD效率的提高(即消除出行和缩短移植时间),而非现金支付,可能会增加配对供者和受者参与KPD的比例。