Wershba Rebecca E, Locke Dona E C, Lanyon Richard I
Department of Psychology, Arizona State University.
Department of Psychiatry and Psychology, Mayo Clinic.
Psychol Assess. 2015 Jun;27(2):733-7. doi: 10.1037/a0038802. Epub 2015 Mar 2.
The use of response bias indicators in psychological measurement has been contentious, with debate as to whether they actually suppress or moderate the ability of substantive psychological indicators to identify the construct of interest. Suppression would indicate that predictor variables contain invalid variance that the bias indicators can suppress, while moderation would indicate differential levels of predictive validity at different levels of bias. Response bias indicators on the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI)-2-Restructured Form (MMPI-2-RF) [infrequent responses (F-r), infrequent somatic responses (Fs), infrequent psychopathology responses (Fp-r), adjustment validity (K-r), uncommon virtues (L-r), symptom validity (FBS-r), and Response Bias Scale (RBS)] were tested to determine whether they suppressed or moderated the ability of the Restructured Clinical Scale 1 (RC1) and Neurologic Complaints (NUC) scale to discriminate between epileptic seizures (ES) and nonepileptic seizures (NES, a conversion disorder that is often misdiagnosed as ES). The MMPI-2-RF was completed by 399 patients with a confirmed diagnosis of ES or NES via Epilepsy Monitoring Unit evaluation. Moderated logistic regression was used to test for moderation, and logistic regression was used to test for suppression. Most of the response bias variables showed a suppressor effect, but moderator effects were not found. These findings extend the use of bias indicators to a psychomedical context.
在心理测量中使用反应偏差指标一直存在争议,关于它们实际上是抑制还是调节实质性心理指标识别感兴趣结构的能力存在争论。抑制表明预测变量包含偏差指标可以抑制的无效方差,而调节则表明在不同偏差水平下预测效度的差异水平。对明尼苏达多相人格问卷(MMPI)-2修订版(MMPI-2-RF)上的反应偏差指标[罕见反应(F-r)、罕见躯体反应(Fs)、罕见精神病理学反应(Fp-r)、调整效度(K-r)、不常见美德(L-r)、症状效度(FBS-r)和反应偏差量表(RBS)]进行了测试,以确定它们是否抑制或调节了重构临床量表1(RC1)和神经学主诉(NUC)量表区分癫痫发作(ES)和非癫痫发作(NES,一种常被误诊为ES的转换障碍)的能力。399名经癫痫监测单元评估确诊为ES或NES的患者完成了MMPI-2-RF测试。使用调节逻辑回归来检验调节作用,使用逻辑回归来检验抑制作用。大多数反应偏差变量显示出抑制效应,但未发现调节效应。这些发现将偏差指标的应用扩展到了心理医学领域。