Johnson David P, Zimmerman Kanecia, Staples Betty, McGann Kathleen A, Frush Karen, Turner David A
Department of Pediatrics, Division of Hospital Medicine, Monroe Carell Jr. Children's Hospital at Vanderbilt, Nashville, Tennessee; and
Department of Pediatrics, and Division of Pediatric Critical Care, Duke Children's Hospital, Durham, North Carolina.
Hosp Pediatr. 2015 Mar;5(3):154-9. doi: 10.1542/hpeds.2014-0050.
Teaching and evaluation of handovers are important requirements of graduate medical education (GME), but well-defined and effective methods have not been clearly established. Case-based computer simulations provide potential methods to teach, evaluate, and practice handovers.
Case-based computer simulation modules were developed. In these modules, trainees care for a virtual patient in a time-lapsed session, followed by real-time synthesis and handover of the clinical information to a partner who uses this information to continue caring for the same patient in a simulated night scenario, with an observer tallying included handover components. The process culminates with evaluator feedback and structured handover education. Surveys were used before and after module implementation to allow the interns to rate the quality of handover provided and record rapid responses and transfers to the ICU.
Fifty-two pediatric and medicine/pediatric residents from 2 institutions participated in the modules. "Anticipatory guidance" elements of the handover were the most frequently excluded (missing at least 1 component in 77% of module handovers). There were no significant differences in the proportion of nights with rapid response calls (7.24% vs 12.79%, P=.052) or transfers to the ICU (7.76% vs 11.27%, P=.21) before and after module implementation.
Case-based, computer-simulation modules are an easily implemented and generalizable mechanism for handover education and assessment. Although significant improvements in patient safety outcomes were not seen as a result of the educational module alone, novel techniques of this nature may supplement handover bundles that have been demonstrated to improve patient safety.
交接班的教学与评估是毕业后医学教育(GME)的重要要求,但尚未明确建立明确有效的方法。基于案例的计算机模拟为教学、评估和练习交接班提供了潜在方法。
开发了基于案例的计算机模拟模块。在这些模块中,受训人员在一个延时环节中照顾一名虚拟患者,然后将临床信息实时综合并交接给一名伙伴,该伙伴在模拟的夜间场景中利用这些信息继续照顾同一名患者,同时有一名观察者记录交接的组成部分。该过程以评估者反馈和结构化的交接班教育告终。在模块实施前后进行了调查,以让实习生对所提供的交接班质量进行评分,并记录快速反应情况以及转至重症监护病房的情况。
来自2家机构的52名儿科及内科/儿科住院医师参与了这些模块。交接班的“预瞻性指导”要素最常被遗漏(在77%的模块交接班中至少缺少1个组成部分)。在模块实施前后,快速反应呼叫的夜间比例(7.24%对12.79%,P = 0.052)或转至重症监护病房的比例(7.76%对11.27%,P = 0.21)没有显著差异。
基于案例的计算机模拟模块是一种易于实施且可推广的交接班教育与评估机制。尽管仅通过该教育模块未观察到患者安全结果有显著改善,但这种性质的新技术可能会补充已被证明可提高患者安全的交接班综合措施。