Pardue S F
Nurs Res. 1979 Sep-Oct;28(5):305-11.
This study evaluated the differences between blocked- and integrated-content baccalaureate nursing programs related to faculty satisfaction, senior students' critical thinking ability, and students' state board examination performance. Faculty satisfaction had 10 factor scores--7 directly teacher-related factors and 3 indirectly teacher-related factors. Analysis of 85 faculty members by a one-dimensional, nested multivariate analysis of variance design revealed that faculty satisfaction was not a function of the type of content program. Analysis of 104 senior students by a one-dimensional, nested univariate analysis of variance design revealed no significant difference in critical-thinking ability between the two types of content programs. When 230 students' SBE scores were subjected to a one-dimensional, nested multivariate analysis of variance, blocked-content program students scored significantly higher than integrated-content program students. Recommendations for further study are made.
本研究评估了模块化课程和整合课程的护理学学士学位项目在教师满意度、高年级学生批判性思维能力以及学生参加州委员会考试成绩方面的差异。教师满意度有10个因子得分——7个与教师直接相关的因子和3个与教师间接相关的因子。采用一维嵌套多变量方差分析设计对85名教师进行分析,结果显示教师满意度与课程内容类型无关。采用一维嵌套单变量方差分析设计对104名高年级学生进行分析,结果显示两种课程内容类型的学生在批判性思维能力方面没有显著差异。对230名学生的州委员会考试成绩进行一维嵌套多变量方差分析时,模块化课程的学生得分显著高于整合课程的学生。本文还提出了进一步研究的建议。