Gong Yanfei, Ericsson K Anders, Moxley Jerad H
School of Psychology and Cognitive Science, East China Normal University, Shanghai, China.
Department of Psychology, Florida State University, Tallahassee, Florida, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2015 Mar 16;10(3):e0118756. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0118756. eCollection 2015.
Individual differences in memory performance in a domain of expertise have traditionally been accounted for by previously acquired chunks of knowledge and patterns. These accounts have been examined experimentally mainly in chess. The role of chunks (clusters of chess pieces recalled in rapid succession during recall of chess positions) and their relations to chess skill are, however, under debate. By introducing an independent chunk-identification technique, namely repeated-recall technique, this study identified individual chunks for particular chess players. The study not only tested chess players with increasing chess expertise, but also tested non-chess players who should not have previously acquired any chess related chunks in memory. For recall of game positions significant differences between players and non-players were found in virtually all the characteristics of chunks recalled. Size of the largest chunks also correlates with chess skill within the group of rated chess players. Further research will help us understand how these memory encodings can explain large differences in chess skill.
在专业领域中,记忆表现的个体差异传统上是由先前习得的知识块和模式来解释的。这些解释主要在国际象棋领域进行了实验检验。然而,知识块(在回忆棋局时快速连续回忆出的棋子组合)的作用及其与国际象棋技能的关系仍存在争议。通过引入一种独立的知识块识别技术,即重复回忆技术,本研究为特定的国际象棋棋手识别出了个体知识块。该研究不仅测试了国际象棋专业水平不断提高的棋手,还测试了那些此前记忆中不应有任何与国际象棋相关知识块的非棋手。对于棋局位置的回忆,棋手和非棋手在几乎所有回忆出的知识块特征上都存在显著差异。在有等级的棋手群体中,最大知识块的大小也与国际象棋技能相关。进一步的研究将帮助我们理解这些记忆编码如何解释国际象棋技能上的巨大差异。