Goodman A J, Neoptolemos J P, Carr-Locke D L, Finlay D B, Fossard D P
Gut. 1985 Feb;26(2):125-32. doi: 10.1136/gut.26.2.125.
Four methods of gall stone diagnosis after an attack of acute pancreatitis are analysed. Of 128 consecutive patients with acute pancreatitis, 99 patients were discharged from hospital without a definite aetiology. These patients had biochemical tests performed on admission and ultrasonography and oral cholecystography performed six weeks later. The sensitivity for ultrasonography was 87% and the specificity was 93%; the respective figures for oral cholecystography were 83% and 90%. The predictive value of positive ultrasonography was 100% and of negative ultrasonography 75%; the respective values for oral cholecystography were 95% and 68%. A combination of ultrasonography and oral cholecystography failed to detect nine of 70 patients with gall stones (13%). Of 35 patients with normal ultrasonography and oral cholecystography, 33 patients had an endoscopic retrograde cholangiogram (ERCP) which showed gall stones in a further seven patients. All three methods failed to reveal gall stones in two patients, confirmed by laparotomy. The sensitivity of admission biochemical analysis was 73% and the specificity was 94%; the predictive value of a positive result was 97% and of a negative result was 57%. Biochemical analysis predicted gall stones in six of the seven patients shown by ERCP. Only 9% of patients were finally considered to be idiopathic. In conclusion ultrasonography is the investigation of choice and ERCP should be undertaken in all patients who have normal ultrasonography and/or oral cholecystography but have biochemical criteria indicative of gall stones.
分析了急性胰腺炎发作后胆结石的四种诊断方法。在连续128例急性胰腺炎患者中,99例患者出院时病因未明确。这些患者入院时进行了生化检查,六周后进行了超声检查和口服胆囊造影。超声检查的敏感性为87%,特异性为93%;口服胆囊造影的相应数字分别为83%和90%。超声检查阳性预测值为100%,阴性预测值为75%;口服胆囊造影的相应值分别为95%和68%。超声检查和口服胆囊造影联合检查未能检测出70例胆结石患者中的9例(13%)。在35例超声检查和口服胆囊造影正常的患者中,33例患者进行了内镜逆行胰胆管造影(ERCP),其中又有7例患者显示有胆结石。所有三种方法均未在2例经剖腹手术证实的患者中发现胆结石。入院生化分析的敏感性为73%,特异性为94%;阳性结果的预测值为97%,阴性结果的预测值为57%。生化分析在ERCP显示的7例患者中的6例中预测到了胆结石。最终只有9%的患者被认为是特发性的。总之,超声检查是首选的检查方法,对于超声检查和/或口服胆囊造影正常但有生化指标提示胆结石的所有患者,均应进行ERCP检查。