Joudi Marjan, Fathi Mehdi, Dalili Amin, Jahanbakhsh Saeed, Merikhi Ardabili Amir, Akhondi Mohsen, Izanloo Azra
Surgical Oncology Research Center, Imam Reza Hospital, Faculty of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
Department of Anesthesiology, Imam Reza Hospital, Faculty of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
Anesth Pain Med. 2014 Nov 16;4(5):e18194. doi: 10.5812/aapm.18194. eCollection 2014 Dec.
Selection of anesthetic approach for lower extremity operations is often a controversial issue for anesthesiologists.
The aim of this study was to compare the incidence and severity of back pain between general and spinal anesthesia, and to find effective factors in developing postoperative back pain.
In a randomized clinical trail, 148 patients with elective lower extremity surgeries were randomly allocated into two groups of 74. The first group received general anesthesia and the second group underwent spinal anesthesia. The incidence of back pain was observed and documented. The severity of back pain was assessed at the first, fourth and eighth postoperative weeks by visual analogue scale.
The mean of patients' age was 35.50 ± 13.34 years. The incidence and mean of back pain severity among all participants were respectively 35.80% and 15.95% at the first week, 7.40% and 2.43% at the fourth week, and 1.4% and 0.27% at the eighth postoperative week. The incidence and mean of back pain severity in spinal group were respectively 39.2% and 18.11% at the first, 12.2% and 3.92% at the fourth, and 2.7% and 0.54% eighth postoperative weeks. In general anesthesia group, these figures were respectively 32.4% and 13.78% at the first week and 2.7% and 0.95% at the fourth postoperative week. No back pain was reported at the eighth postoperative week. The incidence and severity of back pain in the first week showed significant difference between the two groups, while the mean severity of back pain showed significant difference at the fourth week after operation.
Spinal anesthesia could be probably considered as the sole effective factor in the development of back pain after operation.
对于麻醉医生而言,下肢手术麻醉方法的选择常常是一个存在争议的问题。
本研究旨在比较全身麻醉和脊髓麻醉后背痛的发生率及严重程度,并找出术后发生背痛的影响因素。
在一项随机临床试验中,148例行择期下肢手术的患者被随机分为两组,每组74例。第一组接受全身麻醉,第二组接受脊髓麻醉。观察并记录背痛的发生率。术后第1、4和8周采用视觉模拟评分法评估背痛的严重程度。
患者的平均年龄为35.50±13.34岁。所有参与者中,术后第1周背痛的发生率和严重程度平均值分别为35.80%和15.95%,第4周为7.40%和2.43%,术后第8周为1.4%和0.27%。脊髓麻醉组术后第1周背痛的发生率和严重程度平均值分别为39.2%和18.11%,第4周为12.2%和3.92%,第8周为2.7%和0.54%。全身麻醉组在术后第1周这些数值分别为32.4%和13.78%,术后第4周为2.7%和0.95%。术后第8周未报告背痛情况。两组在术后第1周背痛的发生率和严重程度存在显著差异,而术后第4周背痛的严重程度平均值存在显著差异。
脊髓麻醉可能被认为是术后发生背痛的唯一有效因素。