Cho A Ra, Han Sang Ick, Yoon Sang Heon, Park Joo Hyun, Yoo Nam Jin, Kim Sun
MASTER Center for Medical Education Support, The Catholic University of Korea School of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Korean J Med Educ. 2010 Mar;22(1):47-55. doi: 10.3946/kjme.2010.22.1.47. Epub 2010 Mar 31.
The aim of this study was to analyze the results of quantitative and qualitative student evaluations of team-based learning (TBL) and student achievement evaluations during TBL.
Questionnaires that evaluated medical student perception and self-assessment of the TBL experience included 38 questions on the TBL process. Also, we used scores from the TBL session to investigate student academic achievement.
Our results showed that the more proper the educational environments were, the more focused students were on team learning. According to the distribution period for preliminary assignments, there was a difference in self-directed learning. In addition, team members had the opportunity to learn new knowledge by interacting with each other, and when they had the experience of feedback, they understood the instruction topics through team learning better. With regard to peer evaluation, the students who recognized the importance of assessment studied more sincerely and honestly. By experiencing the TBL process, every team showed a high significance in the group readiness assurance test score compared with the individual readiness assurance test score, and student satisfaction with the TBL and expectation levels about capacity strengthening increased as well.
TBL is an effective teaching and learning method and has positive impacts on student academic achievement. A study on student academic achievement and perception of TBL is expected to provide medical educators with suggestions on planning teaching strategies for effective TBL administration.
本研究旨在分析基于团队学习(TBL)的学生定量和定性评价结果以及TBL过程中的学生成绩评价。
评估医学生对TBL体验的认知和自我评估的问卷包括38个关于TBL过程的问题。此外,我们使用TBL课程的分数来调查学生的学业成绩。
我们的结果表明,教育环境越合适,学生对团队学习的关注就越多。根据预习作业的分发时间,自主学习存在差异。此外,团队成员有机会通过相互交流学习新知识,并且当他们有反馈体验时,他们通过团队学习能更好地理解指导主题。关于同伴评价,认识到评价重要性的学生学习更加认真和诚实。通过体验TBL过程,每个团队在小组准备度保证测试分数方面与个人准备度保证测试分数相比都显示出高度显著性,并且学生对TBL的满意度以及对能力提升的期望水平也有所提高。
TBL是一种有效的教学方法,对学生的学业成绩有积极影响。关于学生学业成绩和对TBL的认知的研究有望为医学教育工作者提供有关有效实施TBL教学策略规划的建议。