Zancopé Karla, Abrão Gizella M, Karam Frederick K, Neves Flávio D
Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Department of Occlusion, Fixed Prostheses and Dental Materials, Federal University of Uberlândia, Minas Gerais, Brazil.
Private practice, Uberlândia, Minas Gerais, Brazil.
J Prosthet Dent. 2015 Jun;113(6):528-33.e3. doi: 10.1016/j.prosdent.2014.12.011. Epub 2015 Mar 26.
A number of authors have reported the placement of a distal implant associated with a partial removable dental prosthesis (PRDP) to make this rehabilitation more stable. This strategy may represent an option for resolving the problem of the intrusive movements of the PRDP and for reducing treatment costs.
The purpose of this systematic review was to evaluate the current evidence about the placement of a distal implant associated with a mandibular PRDP to improve patient satisfaction and the clinical performance of the abutment tooth and distal implant.
Two independent prosthetic specialist reviewers conducted this systematic review. The search was performed using selected clinical studies with PRDP associated with distal implants published in English up to May 2014 from the PubMed and Cochrane Library databases. A data extraction form was developed to collect general information: authors, title, year of publication, aim of study, level of evidence, number of participants, number of implants used, implant system, implant length and diameter, abutment type, masticatory performance, patient satisfaction, implant mean bone loss, abutment tooth mean bone loss, prosthetic complications, follow-up period, and implant survival rate. The quality of the selected studies and the risk of bias were also reported.
The initial electronic search identified 231 studies, and the manual process identified 15 studies (total of 246 studies). After the title and abstract reading and the removal of duplicates, the full texts of 43 studies were obtained. The articles that did not meet the inclusion criteria were excluded (28 studies), and the data from 15 studies were extracted. Seven were retrospective studies, 1 a crossover pilot study, 2 case series, 2 paired clinical studies, and 3 case reports, demonstrating that a high number of the selected studies were of low methodological quality. Nevertheless, the high survival rates for PRDP associated with dental implants have been described.
The use of a PRDP associated with dental implants to convert a Kennedy class I to class III dental prosthesis benefits patients by improving their satisfaction and masticatory abilities without decreasing implant survival rates. Considering the abutment tooth survival rate, clinical studies with comparable methodology are still lacking to define protocols regarding the use of distal implants associated with PRDP. Long-term, prospective clinical trials are still needed to understand which implant abutments increase abutment tooth survival rate.
一些作者报道了在部分可摘局部义齿(PRDP)上植入远中种植体,以使这种修复更加稳定。该策略可能是解决PRDP侵入性移动问题和降低治疗成本的一种选择。
本系统评价的目的是评估有关在下颌PRDP上植入远中种植体以提高患者满意度以及基牙和远中种植体临床性能的现有证据。
两名独立的修复专科评审员进行了本系统评价。检索使用了截至2014年5月在PubMed和Cochrane图书馆数据库中发表的与远中种植体相关的PRDP的选定临床研究,检索语言为英文。制定了数据提取表以收集一般信息:作者、标题、发表年份、研究目的、证据水平、参与者数量、使用的种植体数量、种植体系统、种植体长度和直径、基台类型、咀嚼性能、患者满意度、种植体平均骨吸收、基牙平均骨吸收、修复并发症、随访期和种植体存活率。还报告了所选研究的质量和偏倚风险。
初步电子检索识别出231项研究,人工检索识别出15项研究(共246项研究)。在阅读标题和摘要并去除重复项后,获得了43项研究的全文。排除不符合纳入标准的文章(28项研究),提取了15项研究的数据。其中7项为回顾性研究,1项为交叉试点研究,2项为病例系列,2项为配对临床研究,3项为病例报告,表明所选研究中大量研究的方法学质量较低。然而,已报道与牙种植体相关的PRDP具有较高的存活率。
使用与牙种植体相关的PRDP将Kennedy I类牙列缺损转变为III类牙列缺损,可提高患者满意度和咀嚼能力,且不降低种植体存活率,从而使患者受益。考虑到基牙存活率,仍缺乏具有可比方法的临床研究来确定有关与PRDP相关的远中种植体使用的方案。仍需要长期的前瞻性临床试验来了解哪种种植体基台可提高基牙存活率。