Pearson Clare, Littlewood Emma, Douglas Philippa, Robertson Sarah, Gant Timothy W, Hansell Anna L
a Small Area Health Statistics Unit, MRC-PHE Centre for Environment and Health & NIHR HPRU in Health Impact of Environmental Hazards, Imperial College London , London , United Kingdom.
J Toxicol Environ Health B Crit Rev. 2015;18(1):43-69. doi: 10.1080/10937404.2015.1009961.
The number of composting sites in Europe is rapidly increasing, due to efforts to reduce the fraction of waste destined for landfill, but evidence on possible health impacts is limited. This article systematically reviews studies related to bioaerosol exposures within and near composting facilities and associated health effects in both community and occupational health settings. Six electronic databases and bibliographies from January 1960 to July 2014 were searched for studies reporting on health outcomes and/or bioaerosol emissions related to composting sites. Risk of bias was assessed using a customized score. Five hundred and thirty-six papers were identified and reviewed, and 66 articles met the inclusion criteria (48 exposure studies, 9 health studies, 9 health and exposure studies). Exposure information was limited, with most measurements taken in occupational settings and for limited time periods. Bioaerosol concentrations were highest on-site during agitation activities (turning, shredding, and screening). Six studies detected concentrations of either Aspergillus fumigatus or total bacteria above the English Environment Agency's recommended threshold levels beyond 250 m from the site. Occupational studies of compost workers suggested elevated risks of respiratory illnesses with higher bioaerosol exposures. Elevated airway irritation was reported in residents near composting sites, but this may have been affected by reporting bias. The evidence base on health effects of bioaerosol emissions from composting facilities is still limited, although there is sufficient evidence to support a precautionary approach for regulatory purposes. While data to date are suggestive of possible respiratory effects, further study is needed to confirm this and to explore other health outcomes.
由于欧洲致力于减少运往垃圾填埋场的垃圾比例,堆肥场的数量正在迅速增加,但关于其可能对健康产生的影响的证据有限。本文系统回顾了与堆肥设施内部及周边生物气溶胶暴露相关的研究,以及在社区和职业健康环境中产生的相关健康影响。检索了1960年1月至2014年7月期间的六个电子数据库和参考文献,以查找报告与堆肥场相关的健康结果和/或生物气溶胶排放的研究。使用定制评分评估偏倚风险。共识别并审查了536篇论文,其中66篇文章符合纳入标准(48项暴露研究、9项健康研究、9项健康与暴露研究)。暴露信息有限,大多数测量是在职业环境中进行的,且时间有限。在搅拌活动(翻堆、粉碎和筛选)期间,现场生物气溶胶浓度最高。六项研究检测到,在距离堆肥场250米以外的地方,烟曲霉或总细菌的浓度超过了英国环境署建议的阈值水平。对堆肥工人的职业研究表明,生物气溶胶暴露量越高,患呼吸道疾病的风险就越高。据报道,堆肥场附近居民的气道刺激有所增加,但这可能受到报告偏倚的影响。尽管有足够的证据支持出于监管目的采取预防措施,但关于堆肥设施生物气溶胶排放对健康影响的证据基础仍然有限。虽然迄今为止的数据表明可能存在呼吸影响,但仍需要进一步研究来证实这一点,并探索其他健康结果。