Montag Jessica L, MacDonald Maryellen C
Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, Indiana University.
Department of Psychology, University of Wisconsin-Madison.
J Exp Psychol Gen. 2015 Apr;144(2):447-68. doi: 10.1037/xge0000054.
There is still much debate about the nature of the experiential and maturational changes that take place during childhood to bring about the sophisticated language abilities of an adult. The present study investigated text exposure as a possible source of linguistic experience that plays a role in the development of adult-like language abilities. Corpus analyses of object and passive relative clauses (Object: The book that the woman carried; Passive: The book that was carried by the woman) established the frequencies of these sentence types in child-directed speech and children's literature. We found that relative clauses of either type were more frequent in the written corpus, and that the ratio of passive to object relatives was much higher in the written corpus as well. This analysis suggests that passive relative clauses are much more frequent in a child's linguistic environment if they have high rates of text exposure. We then elicited object and passive relative clauses using a picture-description production task with 8- and 12-year-old children and adults. Both group and individual differences were consistent with the corpus analyses, such that older individuals and individuals with more text exposure produced more passive relative clauses. These findings suggest that the qualitatively different patterns of text versus speech may be an important source of linguistic experience for the development of adult-like language behavior.
关于童年时期发生的体验性和成熟性变化的本质,这些变化导致成年人具备复杂的语言能力,目前仍存在诸多争议。本研究调查了文本接触作为一种可能的语言经验来源,其在类似成人语言能力发展中所起的作用。对宾语和被动关系从句(宾语:那个女人拿着的书;被动:被那个女人拿着的书)进行语料库分析,确定了这些句子类型在儿童导向性言语和儿童文学中的出现频率。我们发现,这两种类型的关系从句在书面语料库中更频繁出现,并且书面语料库中被动关系从句与宾语关系从句的比例也更高。该分析表明,如果儿童有较高的文本接触率,被动关系从句在其语言环境中会更为频繁出现。然后,我们使用图片描述生成任务,对8岁、12岁儿童及成年人进行测试,引出宾语和被动关系从句。群体和个体差异均与语料库分析结果一致,即年龄较大的个体以及文本接触较多的个体生成的被动关系从句更多。这些发现表明,文本与言语在性质上的不同模式可能是类似成人语言行为发展的重要语言经验来源。