Howland Renata E, Madsen Ann M, Nicaj Leze, Noe Rebecca S, Casey-Lockyer Mary, Begier Elizabeth
1Bureau of Vital Statistics,New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene,New York,New York.
2Office of Chief Medical Examiner,New York,New York.
Disaster Med Public Health Prep. 2014 Dec;8(6):489-91. doi: 10.1017/dmp.2014.133.
We briefly describe 2 systems that provided disaster-related mortality surveillance during and after Hurricane Sandy in New York City, namely, the New York City Health Department Electronic Death Registration System (EDRS) and the American Red Cross paper-based tracking system.
Red Cross fatality data were linked with New York City EDRS records by using decedent name and date of birth. We analyzed cases identified by both systems for completeness and agreement across selected variables and the time interval between death and reporting in the system.
Red Cross captured 93% (41/44) of all Sandy-related deaths; the completeness and quality varied by item, and timeliness was difficult to determine. The circumstances leading to death captured by Red Cross were particularly useful for identifying reasons individuals stayed in evacuation zones. EDRS variables were nearly 100% complete, and the median interval between date of death and reporting was 6 days (range: 0-43 days).
Our findings indicate that a number of steps have the potential to improve disaster-related mortality surveillance, including updating Red Cross surveillance forms and electronic databases to enhance timeliness assessments, greater collaboration across agencies to share and use data for public health preparedness, and continued expansion of electronic death registration systems.
我们简要描述了纽约市在桑迪飓风期间及之后提供与灾害相关的死亡率监测的两个系统,即纽约市卫生部门电子死亡登记系统(EDRS)和美国红十字会的纸质追踪系统。
通过使用死者姓名和出生日期,将红十字会的死亡数据与纽约市EDRS记录相链接。我们分析了两个系统都识别出的案例,以了解选定变量的完整性和一致性以及死亡与系统报告之间的时间间隔。
红十字会记录了所有与桑迪相关死亡案例中的93%(41/44);完整性和质量因项目而异,及时性难以确定。红十字会所记录的导致死亡的情况对于确定个人留在疏散区的原因特别有用。EDRS变量几乎100%完整,死亡日期与报告之间的中位间隔为6天(范围:0 - 43天)。
我们的研究结果表明,有一些措施有可能改善与灾害相关的死亡率监测,包括更新红十字会的监测表格和电子数据库以加强及时性评估,各机构之间加强合作以共享和使用数据用于公共卫生准备,以及持续扩大电子死亡登记系统。