Stene Lise Eilin, Dyb Grete
Norwegian Centre for Violence and Traumatic Stress Studies, NKVTS, Gullhaugveien 1-3, NO-0484, Oslo, Norway.
Institute of Clinical Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2015 Apr 15;15:158. doi: 10.1186/s12913-015-0811-6.
For effective organization of health services after terror attacks, it is vital to gain insight into survivors' health service utilization. Following the 2011 Utøya mass shooting in Norway, a proactive outreach programme was launched to prevent unmet help needs. All survivors received health services during the first five months, yet an important minority were not proactively followed-up. This study assessed the prevalence of health service utilization and factors associated with mental health service utilization among the survivors 5-15 months after the attack.
The study comprised data from interviews using standardised questionnaires performed 4-5 (T1) and 14-15 (T2) months after the attack. Altogether 281 of 490 (57.3%) survivors answered questions on health service utilization at T2 and were included in this study. Users and non-users of mental health services were compared using Pearson Chi Square tests (categorical variables) and independent t-tests (continuous variables). Multivariate logistic regression analyses were conducted to examine the relationship between mental health service utilization at T2 and early (model 1) and concurrent (model 2) posttraumatic stress reactions, mental distress and somatic symptoms. Both models were adjusted for age, gender and predisaster utilization of mental health services.
Altogether 267 (95.0%) of 281 survivors reported contact with health services at T2, including 254 (90.4%) with ≥1 types of primary care services; and 192 (68.3%) with mental health services. In bivariate analyses, mental health service utilization was associated with female gender, injuries, PTSD, mental distress, somatic symptoms, and sleep problems. After multivariate adjustments for early symptom levels (model 1), only mental distress remained significantly associated with mental health service utilization at T2 (OR 2.8, 95% CI 1.2-6.8). In the analysis adjusting for concurrent symptom levels (model 2), only somatic symptoms were associated with mental health service utilization (OR 4.4, 95% CI 1.8-10.8).
The high utilization of both primary and secondary health services among young survivors 5-15 months after the attack underscores the importance of allocating resources to meet the increased demand for services over a longer time period. The results further highlight the need to address somatic symptoms in disaster survivors who receive mental health services.
为了在恐怖袭击后有效组织卫生服务,深入了解幸存者对卫生服务的利用情况至关重要。2011年挪威于特岛大规模枪击事件后,启动了一项积极的外展计划,以防止出现未得到满足的帮助需求。所有幸存者在最初五个月内都接受了卫生服务,但仍有一小部分重要人群未得到积极随访。本研究评估了袭击发生5至15个月后幸存者中卫生服务利用的患病率以及与心理健康服务利用相关的因素。
该研究包括袭击发生后4至5个月(T1)和14至15个月(T2)使用标准化问卷进行访谈的数据。490名幸存者中有281名(57.3%)在T2时回答了关于卫生服务利用的问题,并被纳入本研究。使用Pearson卡方检验(分类变量)和独立t检验(连续变量)对心理健康服务的使用者和非使用者进行比较。进行多变量逻辑回归分析,以检验T2时心理健康服务利用与早期(模型1)和同期(模型2)创伤后应激反应、精神痛苦和躯体症状之间的关系。两个模型均针对年龄、性别和灾难前心理健康服务的利用情况进行了调整。
281名幸存者中有267名(95.0%)报告在T2时与卫生服务有接触,其中254名(90.4%)使用了≥1种初级保健服务;192名(68.3%)使用了心理健康服务。在双变量分析中,心理健康服务利用与女性性别、受伤、创伤后应激障碍、精神痛苦、躯体症状和睡眠问题有关。在对早期症状水平进行多变量调整后(模型1),只有精神痛苦仍与T2时的心理健康服务利用显著相关(比值比2.8,95%置信区间1.2 - 6.8)。在对同期症状水平进行调整的分析中(模型2),只有躯体症状与心理健康服务利用有关(比值比4.4,95%置信区间1.8 - 10.8)。
袭击发生5至15个月后,年轻幸存者对初级和二级卫生服务的高利用率凸显了在较长时期内分配资源以满足服务需求增加的重要性。结果进一步强调了在接受心理健康服务的灾难幸存者中解决躯体症状的必要性。