Naclerio Fernando, Larumbe-Zabala Eneko, Cooper Robert, Allgrove Judith, Earnest Conrad P
Center for Sport Sciences and Human Performance, University of Greenwich, Medway, United Kingdom.
Clinical Research Institute, Texas Tech University, Health Sciences Center, Lubbock, Texas, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2015 Apr 27;10(4):e0125188. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0125188. eCollection 2015.
We investigated the effects of ingesting a multi-ingredient (53 g carbohydrate, 14.5 g whey protein, 5 g glutamine, 1.5 g L-carnitine-L-tartrate) supplement, carbohydrate only, or placebo on intermittent performance, perception of fatigue, immunity, and functional and metabolic markers of recovery. Sixteen amateur soccer players ingested their respective treatments before, during and after performing a 90-min intermittent repeated sprint test. Primary outcomes included time for a 90-min intermittent repeated sprint test (IRS) followed by eleven 15 m sprints. Measurements included creatine kinase, myoglobin, interleukine-6, Neutrophil; Lymphocytes and Monocyte before (pre), immediately after (post), 1 h and 24 h after exercise testing period. Overall, time for the IRS and 15 m sprints was not different between treatments. However, the perception of fatigue was attenuated (P<0.001) for the multi-ingredient (15.9±1.4) vs. placebo (17.8±1.4) but not for the carbohydrate (17.0±1.9) condition. Several changes in immune/inflammatory indices were noted as creatine kinase peaked at 24 h while Interleukin-6 and myoglobin increased both immediately after and at 1 h compared with baseline (P<0.05) for all three conditions. However, Myoglobin (P<0.05) was lower 1 h post-exercise for the multi-ingredient (241.8±142.6 ng·ml(-1)) and CHO (265.4±187.8 ng·ml(-1)) vs. placebo (518.6±255.2 ng·ml(-1)). Carbohydrate also elicited lower neutrophil concentrations vs. multi-ingredient (3.9±1.5 10(9)/L vs. 4.9±1.8 10(9)/L, P = 0.016) and a reduced (P<0.05) monocytes count (0.36±0.09 10(9)/L) compared to both multi-ingredient (0.42±0.09 10(9)/L) and placebo (0.42±0.12 10(9)/L). In conclusion, multi-ingredient and carbohydrate supplements did not improve intermittent performance, inflammatory or immune function. However, both treatments did attenuate serum myoglobin, while only carbohydrate blunted post-exercise leukocytosis.
我们研究了摄入一种多成分补充剂(53克碳水化合物、14.5克乳清蛋白、5克谷氨酰胺、1.5克左旋肉碱酒石酸盐)、仅摄入碳水化合物或安慰剂对间歇性运动表现、疲劳感、免疫力以及恢复的功能和代谢指标的影响。16名业余足球运动员在进行90分钟间歇性重复冲刺测试之前、期间和之后摄入各自的处理物。主要结果包括90分钟间歇性重复冲刺测试(IRS)以及随后11次15米冲刺的时间。测量指标包括运动测试期之前(运动前)、之后立即(运动后)、运动后1小时和24小时的肌酸激酶、肌红蛋白、白细胞介素-6、中性粒细胞、淋巴细胞和单核细胞。总体而言,不同处理之间IRS和15米冲刺的时间没有差异。然而,与安慰剂组(17.8±1.4)相比,多成分组(15.9±1.4)的疲劳感有所减轻(P<0.001),而碳水化合物组(17.0±1.9)则没有。注意到免疫/炎症指标有一些变化,所有三种情况的肌酸激酶在24小时达到峰值,而白细胞介素-6和肌红蛋白在运动后立即和1小时均较基线水平升高(P<0.05)。然而,与安慰剂组(518.6±255.2纳克·毫升⁻¹)相比,多成分组(241.8±142.6纳克·毫升⁻¹)和碳水化合物组(265.4±187.8纳克·毫升⁻¹)运动后1小时的肌红蛋白水平较低(P<0.05)。与多成分组(4.9±1.8×10⁹/L)相比,碳水化合物组的中性粒细胞浓度也较低(3.9±1.5×10⁹/L,P = 0.016),且与多成分组(0.42±0.09×10⁹/L)和安慰剂组(0.42±0.12×10⁹/L)相比,单核细胞计数降低(P<0.05)(0.36±0.09×10⁹/L)。总之,多成分补充剂和碳水化合物补充剂并未改善间歇性运动表现、炎症或免疫功能。然而,两种处理都降低了血清肌红蛋白水平,而只有碳水化合物减轻了运动后白细胞增多。