Torta Diana M, Legrain Valéry, Mouraux André
Institute of Neuroscience (IoNS), Université catholique de Louvain, Brussels, Belgium.
Psychophysiology. 2015 Aug;52(8):1010-8. doi: 10.1111/psyp.12439. Epub 2015 Apr 27.
Previous studies have suggested that looking at the hand can reduce the perception of pain and the magnitude of the ERPs elicited by nociceptive stimuli delivered onto the hand. In contrast, other studies have suggested that looking at the hand can increase tactile sensory discrimination performance, and enhance the magnitude of the ERPs elicited by tactile stimulation. These opposite effects could be related to differences in the crossmodal effects between vision, nociception, and touch. However, these differences could also be related to the use of different experimental designs. Importantly, most studies on the effects of vision on pain have relied on a mirror to create the illusion that the reflected hand is a direct view of the stimulated hand. Here, we compared the effects of direct versus mirror vision of the hand versus an object on the perception and ERPs elicited by non-nociceptive and nociceptive stimuli. We did not observe any significant effect of vision on the perceived intensity. However, vision of the hand did reduce the magnitude of the nociceptive N240 wave, and enhanced the magnitude of the non-nociceptive P200. Our results confirm that vision of the body differentially affects nociceptive and non-nociceptive processing, but question the robustness of visual analgesia.
先前的研究表明,注视手部可以减轻疼痛感知以及由施加在手部的伤害性刺激所引发的事件相关电位(ERP)的幅度。相比之下,其他研究表明,注视手部可以提高触觉感觉辨别能力,并增强由触觉刺激所引发的ERP的幅度。这些相反的效应可能与视觉、伤害感受和触觉之间跨模态效应的差异有关。然而,这些差异也可能与使用不同的实验设计有关。重要的是,大多数关于视觉对疼痛影响的研究都依赖于镜子来制造一种错觉,即反射的手部是对受刺激手部的直接观察。在此,我们比较了直接观察手部与通过镜子观察手部以及观察物体对由非伤害性和伤害性刺激所引发的感知和ERP的影响。我们没有观察到视觉对感知强度有任何显著影响。然而,注视手部确实降低了伤害性N240波的幅度,并增强了非伤害性P200波的幅度。我们的结果证实,对身体的视觉会以不同方式影响伤害性和非伤害性处理,但对视觉镇痛的稳健性提出了质疑。