Miyasaka Kiyoyuki W, Martin Niels D, Pascual Jose L, Buchholz Joseph, Aggarwal Rajesh
Department of Surgery, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Department of Surgery, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
J Surg Educ. 2015 Sep-Oct;72(5):803-10. doi: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2015.03.001. Epub 2015 Apr 23.
Expectations continue to rise for residency programs to provide integrated simulation training to address clinical competence. How to implement such training sustainably remains a challenge. We developed a compact module for first-year surgery residents integrating theory with practice in high-fidelity simulations, to reinforce the preparedness and confidence of junior residents in their ability to manage common emergent patient care scenarios in trauma and critical care surgery.
The 3-day module features a combination of simulated patient encounters using standardized patients and electronic manikins, didactic sessions, and hands-on training. Manikin-based scenarios developed in-house were used to teach trauma and critical care management concepts and skills. Separate scenarios in collaboration with the regional organ donation program addressed communication in difficult situations such as brain death. Didactic material based on contemporary evidence, as well as skills stations, was developed to complement the scenarios. Residents were surveyed before and after training on their confidence in meeting the 14 learning objectives of the curriculum on a 5-point Likert scale.
Data from 15 residents who underwent this training show an overall improvement in confidence across all learning objectives defined for the module, with confidence scores before to after training improving significantly from 2.8 (σ = 0.85, median = 3) to 3.9 (σ = 0.87, median = 4) of 5, p < 0.001. Although female residents reported higher posttraining confidence scores compared with male residents (average 4.2 female vs 3.8 male, p = 0.002), there were no other significant differences in confidence scores or changes to scores owing to resident sex or program status (categorical or preliminary).
We successfully implemented a multimodal simulation-based curriculum that provides skills training integrated with the clinical context of managing trauma and critical care patients, simultaneously addressing a range of clinical competencies. Results to date show consistent improvement in residents' confidence in meeting learning objectives. Development of the curriculum continues for sustainability, as well as measures to embed objective evaluations of resident competence.
对于住院医师培训项目提供综合模拟培训以提升临床能力的期望持续升高。如何可持续地实施此类培训仍是一项挑战。我们为一年级外科住院医师开发了一个紧凑模块,将理论与高保真模拟实践相结合,以增强初级住院医师应对创伤和重症监护手术中常见紧急患者护理场景的准备程度和信心。
这个为期3天的模块包括使用标准化患者和电子模拟人进行模拟患者诊疗、教学课程以及实践培训。内部开发的基于模拟人的场景用于教授创伤和重症监护管理概念及技能。与地区器官捐赠项目合作设计的单独场景用于处理诸如脑死亡等困难情况下的沟通问题。基于当代证据的教学材料以及技能培训站也得以开发,以补充这些场景。在培训前后,通过5点李克特量表对住院医师在达成课程14项学习目标方面的信心进行调查。
15名接受该培训的住院医师的数据显示,在该模块所定义的所有学习目标方面,信心总体有所提升。培训前至培训后的信心得分从2.8(标准差=0.85,中位数=3)显著提高至3.9(标准差=0.87,中位数=4)(满分5分),p<0.001。尽管女性住院医师报告的培训后信心得分高于男性住院医师(女性平均4.2分,男性平均3.8分,p=0.002),但在信心得分或得分变化方面,因住院医师性别或项目状态(分类或初步)并无其他显著差异。
我们成功实施了一个基于多模式模拟的课程,该课程提供与创伤和重症监护患者管理临床背景相结合的技能培训,同时涵盖一系列临床能力。迄今为止的结果表明,住院医师在达成学习目标方面的信心持续提高。课程开发仍在继续,以实现可持续性,并采取措施对住院医师能力进行客观评估。