Wang Biqi, Gao Wenjing, Yu Canqing, Cao Weihua, Lv Jun, Wang Shengfeng, Pang Zengchang, Cong Liming, Wang Hua, Wu Xianping, Li Liming
Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, School of Public Health, Peking University, Beijing, 100191, China.
Qingdao Center for Diseases Control and Prevention, Qingdao, 266033, China.
PLoS One. 2015 Apr 30;10(4):e0123992. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0123992. eCollection 2015.
Previous studies have shown that both single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and questionnaires-based method can be used for twin zygosity determination, but few validation studies have been conducted using Chinese populations. In the current study, we recruited 192 same sex Chinese adult twin pairs to evaluate the validity of using genetic markers-based method and questionnaire-based method in zygosity determination. We considered the relatedness analysis based on more than 0.6 million SNPs genotyping as the golden standards for zygosity determination. After quality control, qualified twins were left for relatedness analysis based on identical by descent calculation. Then those same sex twin pairs were included in the zygosity questionnaire validation analysis. Logistic regression model was applied to assess the discriminant ability of age, sex and the three questions in zygosity determination. Leave one out cross-validation was used as a measurement of internal validation. The results of zygosity determination based on 65 SNPs in 450k methylation array were all consistent with genotyping. Age, gender, questions of appearance confused by strangers and previously perceived zygosity consisted of the most predictable model with a consistency rate of 0.8698, cross validation predictive error of 0.1347. For twin studies with genotyping and\or 450k methylation array, there would be no need to conduct other zygosity testing for the sake of costs consideration.
先前的研究表明,单核苷酸多态性(SNP)和基于问卷的方法均可用于双生子合子性判定,但针对中国人群进行的验证研究较少。在本研究中,我们招募了192对同性别的中国成年双胞胎,以评估基于基因标记的方法和基于问卷的方法在合子性判定中的有效性。我们将基于超过60万个SNP基因分型的亲缘关系分析视为合子性判定的金标准。经过质量控制后,合格的双胞胎被留作基于同源性计算的亲缘关系分析。然后,将那些同性别的双胞胎对纳入合子性问卷验证分析。应用逻辑回归模型评估年龄、性别和三个合子性判定问题的判别能力。留一法交叉验证用作内部验证的一种度量。基于450k甲基化芯片中65个SNP的合子性判定结果与基因分型结果完全一致。年龄、性别、被陌生人混淆的外貌问题以及先前感知的合子性构成了预测性最强的模型,一致性率为0.8698,交叉验证预测误差为0.1347。对于进行基因分型和/或450k甲基化芯片检测的双胞胎研究,出于成本考虑,无需进行其他合子性检测。