Bruno Amy E, Sethares Kristen A
Questions or comments about this article may be directed to Amy E. Bruno, PhD(c) ANP-C, at
J Neurosci Nurs. 2015 Jun;47(3):146-53. doi: 10.1097/JNN.0000000000000131.
Fatigue, one of the most prevalent and underassessed nonmotor symptoms in patients with Parkinson disease (PD), is reported to be a major cause of disability and reduced quality of life. The purpose of this review was to systematically examine the scientific literature and report how fatigue is defined and measured and what interventions are used to treat it. A synthesis of the current literature will expose the current state of the science of fatigue in PD, propose areas for future research, and offer practice implications. An integrative review of the literature was conducted. The electronic databases CINAHL, Psychinfo, and PUBMED were searched using the keywords "Parkinson's disease," "fatigue," "definition," "mental fatigue," "physical fatigue," "measurement," "interventions," "treatment," and "methylphenidate." One hundred fourteen articles were found. Nineteen studies met review criteria. No universal definition of fatigue in PD was found, making it difficult to measure. However, central, physical, mental, and peripheral fatigues were described. Six scales were found that measure fatigue in PD; only one specific to PD, the Parkinson Fatigue Scale, measured physical fatigue. Seven studies reported interventions to treat fatigue and were categorized as medication, exercise, and alternative interventions. None of these interventions had a significant effect on fatigue. Findings showed that (a) there is a lack of a universally accepted definition of fatigue because of its subjective nature, (b) existing fatigue measurement tools do not measure all types of fatigue in PD, and (c) no intervention had a significant effect on fatigue. There is a need to define and explore fatigue further using qualitative methods. Further development of instruments to measure fatigue in women, younger onset, and older adults with PD is needed. A focus on person-centered interventions to reduce fatigue in patients with PD is a research priority.
疲劳是帕金森病(PD)患者中最普遍且评估不足的非运动症状之一,据报道是导致残疾和生活质量下降的主要原因。本综述的目的是系统地研究科学文献,并报告疲劳是如何定义和测量的,以及使用了哪些干预措施来治疗疲劳。对当前文献的综合分析将揭示PD中疲劳科学的现状,提出未来研究的领域,并提供实践启示。对文献进行了综合综述。使用关键词“帕金森病”“疲劳”“定义”“精神疲劳”“身体疲劳”“测量”“干预措施”“治疗”和“哌甲酯”搜索了电子数据库CINAHL、Psychinfo和PUBMED。共找到114篇文章。19项研究符合综述标准。未发现PD中疲劳的通用定义,这使得测量变得困难。然而,描述了中枢性、身体性、精神性和外周性疲劳。发现有六种量表可测量PD中的疲劳;只有一种特定于PD的帕金森疲劳量表测量身体疲劳。七项研究报告了治疗疲劳的干预措施,并分为药物、运动和替代干预措施。这些干预措施均未对疲劳产生显著影响。研究结果表明:(a)由于疲劳的主观性,缺乏普遍接受的定义;(b)现有的疲劳测量工具不能测量PD中所有类型的疲劳;(c)没有干预措施对疲劳有显著影响。需要使用定性方法进一步定义和探索疲劳。需要进一步开发用于测量PD女性、早发型和老年患者疲劳的工具。关注以患者为中心的干预措施以减轻PD患者的疲劳是一个研究重点。