Häfner H, Riecher A, Maurer K, Löffler W, Munk-Jørgensen P, Strömgren E
Central Institute of Mental Health, Schizophrenia Research Unit, Mannheim, FRG.
Psychol Med. 1989 Nov;19(4):903-18. doi: 10.1017/s0033291700005626.
Numerous studies have reported a lower mean age at first hospitalization for schizophrenia in males than in females. For this finding not only a gender difference in age at first onset of schizophrenia, but also other factors can be responsible. With the aim of providing a comprehensive analysis of gender differences in onset, symptomatology and course of schizophrenia, we started by testing the hypothesis postulating a gender difference in mean age at first hospitalization. By using the Danish and the Mannheim psychiatric case registers we analysed all hospital admissions for schizophrenia and related diagnoses and all previous admissions for other diagnoses of the Danish population in 1976 and those of the inhabitants of the German city of Mannheim in the period of 1978-80. Artefacts were controlled for systematically. The impact of intervening variables such as selection factors as well as the influence of gender on the ascription of a diagnosis of schizophrenia for the first time were assessed. We found a mean difference of 5 to 6 years in age at first hospitalization between males and females in both countries when a broad definition of the diagnosis was used and of 4 to 5 years when a restrictive definition was applied. The higher mean age at first hospitalization among females is not attributable to artefacts, diagnostic procedures or to any essential extent to gender differences in help-seeking behaviour or occupational status. When a distinction was made between 'single' and 'married', the significant difference in age at first hospitalization between the sexes disappeared in singles. With case register data and without knowing the chronological order of marriage and onset of the disease, it remains an open question whether this finding can be explained by purely correlative associations between sex, marital status and age of onset or by causal effects.
许多研究报告称,男性首次因精神分裂症住院的平均年龄低于女性。对于这一发现,不仅精神分裂症首次发病的年龄存在性别差异,其他因素也可能起作用。为了全面分析精神分裂症发病、症状及病程中的性别差异,我们首先检验了关于首次住院平均年龄存在性别差异的假设。通过使用丹麦和曼海姆的精神病病例登记册,我们分析了1976年丹麦人口中所有因精神分裂症及相关诊断的住院情况以及所有先前因其他诊断的住院情况,以及1978 - 1980年德国曼海姆市居民的住院情况。对人为因素进行了系统控制。评估了诸如选择因素等干预变量的影响以及性别对首次诊断为精神分裂症的归因的影响。我们发现,当采用宽泛的诊断定义时,两国男性和女性首次住院的年龄平均相差5至6岁;当采用严格的诊断定义时,相差4至5岁。女性首次住院的平均年龄较高并非归因于人为因素、诊断程序,在很大程度上也不归因于求助行为或职业状况方面的性别差异。当区分“单身”和“已婚”时,单身者中两性首次住院年龄的显著差异消失了。利用病例登记数据且不知道婚姻和疾病发病的时间顺序,这一发现究竟是可以由性别、婚姻状况和发病年龄之间的纯粹相关关联来解释,还是由因果效应来解释,仍然是一个悬而未决的问题。