Miller Melissa A, Govindan Sushant, Watson Sam R, Hyzy Robert C, Iwashyna Theodore J
1 Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
2 Michigan Health and Hospital Association Keystone Center, Lansing, Michigan; and.
Ann Am Thorac Soc. 2015 Jul;12(7):1066-71. doi: 10.1513/AnnalsATS.201501-066OC.
A bundled approach to intensive care unit (ICU) care known as "Awakening and Breathing Coordination, Delirium monitoring/management, and Early exercise/mobility" (ABCDE) has been proposed, with evidence supporting individual interventions as well as the bundle as a whole. Few data exist on the bundle's implementation and efficacy in community practice.
To evaluate self-reported rates of implementation of ABCDE components and their association with outcomes in a state-wide quality improvement collaborative.
A written survey was administered to representatives attending the 2012 annual meeting of the Michigan Health and Hospital Association's Keystone ICU collaborative. Respondents reported on their practices regarding spontaneous awakening trials, delirium assessments, and early mobility.
There were 212 respondents, a 76% response rate. Wide variation in focus was noted across the assessed components of ABCDE. Only 12% reported having implemented routine spontaneous awakening trials and delirium assessments as well as early mobility, 36% reported not having early mobility as an active goal in their units (nonmovers), and 52% reported attempts at early mobility without both routine sedation interruption and delirium screening implementation. In adjusted models, those who implemented exercise with sedation interruption and delirium screening were 3.5 (95% confidence interval, 1.4-8.6) times more likely to achieve higher levels of exercise in ventilated patients than those who implemented exercise without both sedation interruption and delirium screening.
There is incomplete penetrance of aspects of ABCDE across ICUs in this highly motivated statewide quality improvement collaborative. Yet, implementation of exercise in the context of both sedation interruption and delirium screening was associated with improved self-reported mobility outcomes. Effective knowledge translation and implementation strategies may offer substantial benefits to ICU patients.
一种被称为“唤醒与呼吸协调、谵妄监测/管理以及早期活动/运动能力”(ABCDE)的重症监护病房(ICU)护理综合方法已被提出,有证据支持其中的各项干预措施以及整个护理综合方案。关于该护理综合方案在社区实践中的实施情况和效果的数据很少。
评估在全州范围的质量改进协作中,ABCDE各组成部分的自我报告实施率及其与结果的关联。
对参加密歇根州卫生与医院协会关键ICU协作组织2012年年会的代表进行书面调查。受访者报告了他们在自主唤醒试验、谵妄评估和早期活动方面的做法。
共有212名受访者,回复率为76%。ABCDE评估组件的重点存在很大差异。只有12%的受访者报告已实施常规自主唤醒试验、谵妄评估以及早期活动,36%的受访者报告其所在科室未将早期活动作为积极目标(不进行早期活动者),52%的受访者报告尝试进行早期活动,但未同时实施常规镇静中断和谵妄筛查。在调整模型中,与未同时实施镇静中断和谵妄筛查而进行早期活动的人相比,同时实施镇静中断、谵妄筛查和早期活动的人使通气患者达到更高活动水平的可能性高3.5倍(95%置信区间,1.4 - 8.6)。
在这个积极性很高的全州范围质量改进协作中,ABCDE各方面在ICU中的实施并不完全。然而,在镇静中断和谵妄筛查的背景下实施早期活动与自我报告的活动能力改善结果相关。有效的知识转化和实施策略可能会给ICU患者带来巨大益处。