Arias Eric J, Dunn Gavin P, Washington Chad W, Derdeyn Colin P, Chicoine Michael R, Grubb Robert L, Moran Christopher J, Cross DeWitte T, Dacey Ralph G, Zipfel Gregory J
Department of Neurological Surgery, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, Missouri.
Department of Neurological Surgery, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, Missouri.
J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis. 2015 Jul;24(7):1597-608. doi: 10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2015.03.053. Epub 2015 May 9.
North American and Asian forms of moyamoya have distinct clinical characteristics. Asian adults with moyamoya are known to respond better to direct versus indirect revascularization. It is unclear whether North American adults with moyamoya have a similar long-term angiographic response to direct versus indirect bypass.
A retrospective review of surgical revascularization for adult moyamoya phenomenon was performed. Preoperative and postoperative cerebral angiograms underwent consensus review, with degree of revascularization quantified as extent of new middle cerebral artery (MCA) territory filling.
Late angiographic follow-up was available in 15 symptomatic patients who underwent 20 surgical revascularization procedures. In 10 hemispheres treated solely with indirect arterial bypass, 3 had 2/3 revascularization, 4 had 1/3 revascularization, and 3 had no revascularization of the MCA territory. In the 10 hemispheres treated with direct arterial bypass (8 as a stand-alone procedure and 2 in combination with an indirect procedure), 2 had complete revascularization, 7 had 2/3 revascularization, and 1 had 1/3 revascularization. Direct bypass provided a higher rate of "good" angiographic outcome (complete or 2/3 revascularization) when compared with indirect techniques (P = .0198).
Direct bypass provides a statistically significant, more consistent, and complete cerebral revascularization than indirect techniques in this patient population. This is similar to that reported in the Asian literature, which suggests that the manner of presentation (ischemia in North American adults versus hemorrhage in Asian adults) is likely not a contributor to the extent of revascularization achieved after surgical intervention.
北美型和亚洲型烟雾病具有不同的临床特征。已知亚洲成年烟雾病患者对直接血运重建术与间接血运重建术的反应更好。目前尚不清楚北美成年烟雾病患者对直接旁路手术与间接旁路手术是否有相似的长期血管造影反应。
对成年烟雾病现象的手术血运重建进行回顾性研究。术前和术后脑血管造影进行了一致性评估,血运重建程度以大脑中动脉(MCA)新供血区域的范围进行量化。
15例有症状患者接受了20次手术血运重建,可获得晚期血管造影随访结果。在仅接受间接动脉旁路手术治疗的10个半球中,3个半球实现了2/3血运重建,4个半球实现了1/3血运重建,3个半球未实现MCA区域血运重建。在接受直接动脉旁路手术治疗的10个半球中(8例为单独手术,2例与间接手术联合),2个半球实现了完全血运重建,7个半球实现了2/3血运重建,1个半球实现了1/3血运重建。与间接技术相比,直接旁路手术获得“良好”血管造影结果(完全或2/3血运重建)的比例更高(P = 0.0198)。
在该患者群体中,与间接技术相比,直接旁路手术能提供统计学上显著、更一致且更完全的脑血运重建。这与亚洲文献报道相似,提示临床表现方式(北美成年患者为缺血,亚洲成年患者为出血)可能并非手术干预后血运重建程度的影响因素。