Leonard Westgate Christine, Shiner Brian, Thompson Paul, Watts Bradley V
Ms. Leonard Westgate is with the Research Service of the White River Junction Veterans Affairs (VA) Medical Center, White River Junction, Vermont, where Dr. Shiner is with the Department of Mental Health and Behavioral Science Service and Dr. Watts is with the National Center for Patient Safety Field Office (e-mail:
Psychiatr Serv. 2015 Oct;66(10):1051-6. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201400283. Epub 2015 Jun 15.
Many people who die from suicide received recent medical care prior to their death. Suicide risk assessment tools for health care settings focus on a variety of clinical and demographic factors but generally do not examine the text of notes written by clinicians about patients who later die from suicide. This study examined whether clinicians' notes indicated increased use of distancing language during the year preceding patients' suicide.
The linguistic content of clinicians' notes for outpatients of U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) medical centers was examined in the year preceding suicide of 63 veterans. Approximately half of the veterans had received mental health services. They were matched based on mental health service use with living VA outpatients. Linguistics software was used to construct quantitative theme-based categories related to distancing language and to examine temporal trends via keyword analysis.
Analysis of clinical notes for outpatients who died from suicide and those who did not revealed a significant difference in clinicians' distancing language. Multiple keywords emerged that also were related to distancing language, and their relative frequency increased in the time approaching the suicide.
Linguistic analysis is a promising approach to identify use of distancing language by clinicians, which appears to be a marker of suicide risk. This pilot work indicates that additional analysis and validation with larger cohorts are warranted.
许多自杀身亡的人在死前接受过近期的医疗护理。医疗环境中的自杀风险评估工具侧重于各种临床和人口统计学因素,但通常不会检查临床医生为后来自杀身亡的患者所写记录的文本。本研究调查了临床医生的记录是否表明在患者自杀前一年中使用疏离性语言的情况有所增加。
对美国退伍军人事务部(VA)医疗中心63名退伍军人自杀前一年的门诊临床医生记录的语言内容进行了检查。大约一半的退伍军人接受过心理健康服务。根据心理健康服务使用情况,将他们与在世的VA门诊患者进行匹配。使用语言学软件构建与疏离性语言相关的基于主题的定量类别,并通过关键词分析检查时间趋势。
对自杀身亡和未自杀身亡的门诊患者的临床记录分析显示,临床医生的疏离性语言存在显著差异。出现了多个与疏离性语言相关的关键词,并且在接近自杀时它们的相对频率增加。
语言分析是识别临床医生使用疏离性语言的一种有前景的方法,这似乎是自杀风险的一个标志。这项试点工作表明,有必要对更大的队列进行进一步分析和验证。