Oosterhoff Thijs C H, Nota Sjoerd P F T, Ring David
Orthopaedic Hand Service, Yawkey Center, Suite 2100, Massachusetts General Hospital, 55 Fruit Street, Boston, MA 02114 USA.
J Hand Microsurg. 2015 Jun;7(1):13-7. doi: 10.1007/s12593-014-0151-5. Epub 2014 Nov 13.
Background Finger stiffness varies substantially in patients with hand and upper extremity illness and can be notably more than expected for a given pathophysiology. In prior studies, pain intensity and magnitude of disability consistently correlate with coping strategies such as catastrophic thinking and kinesiophobia, which can be characterized as overprotectiveness. In this retrospective study we address the primary research question whether patients with finger stiffness are more often overprotective when the primary pathology is outside the hand (e.g. distal radius fracture) than when it is located within the hand. Methods In an orthopaedic hand surgery department 160 patients diagnosed with more finger stiffness than expected for a given pathophysiology or time point of recovery between December 2006 and September 2012 were analyzed to compare the proportion of patients characterized as overprotective for differences by site of pathology: (1) inside the hand, (2) outside the hand, and (3) psychiatric etiology (e.g. clenched fist). Results Among 160 subjects with more finger stiffness than expected, 132 (82 %) were characterized as overprotective including 88 of 108 (81 %) with pathology in the hand, 39 of 44 (89 %) with pathology outside the hand, and 5 of 8 (63 %) with psychiatric etiology. These differences were not significant. Conclusions Overprotectiveness is common in patients with more finger stiffness than expected regardless the site and type of primary pathology. It seems worthwhile to recognize and treat maladaptive coping strategies early during recovery to limit impairment, symptoms, and disability.
手部和上肢疾病患者的手指僵硬程度差异很大,对于特定的病理生理学情况,其僵硬程度可能明显超过预期。在先前的研究中,疼痛强度和残疾程度与诸如灾难性思维和运动恐惧等应对策略始终相关,这些应对策略可被描述为过度保护。在这项回顾性研究中,我们探讨了一个主要研究问题,即当主要病理情况在手外(例如桡骨远端骨折)时,手指僵硬的患者是否比主要病理情况在手内时更常表现出过度保护。
在一个整形外科手部手术科室,对2006年12月至2012年9月期间诊断出手指僵硬程度超过给定病理生理学或恢复时间点预期的160例患者进行分析,以比较按病理部位分类的过度保护患者比例:(1)手内,(2)手外,以及(3)精神病因(例如握拳)。
在160例手指僵硬程度超过预期的受试者中,132例(82%)被归类为过度保护,其中手内病理情况的108例中有88例(81%),手外病理情况的44例中有39例(89%),精神病因的8例中有5例(63%)。这些差异不显著。
无论主要病理情况的部位和类型如何,过度保护在手指僵硬程度超过预期的患者中很常见。在恢复早期识别并治疗适应不良的应对策略以限制损伤、症状和残疾似乎是值得的。