Mattes Malcolm D, Patel Krishnan R, Burt Lindsay M, Hirsch Ariel E
Department of Radiation Oncology, West Virginia University School of Medicine, PO Box 9234, One Medical Center Drive, Morgantown, WV, USA.
Department of Radiation Oncology, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA.
J Cancer Educ. 2016 Dec;31(4):679-686. doi: 10.1007/s13187-015-0872-6.
Cancer is the second leading cause of death in the USA, but there is minimal data on how oncology is taught to medical students. The purpose of this study is to characterize oncology education at US medical schools. An electronic survey was sent between December 2014 and February 2015 to a convenience sample of medical students who either attended the American Society for Radiation Oncology annual meeting or serve as delegates to the American Association of Medical Colleges. Information on various aspects of oncology instruction at participants' medical schools was collected. Seventy-six responses from students in 28 states were received. Among the six most common causes of death in the USA, cancer reportedly received the fourth most curricular time. During the first, second, and third years of medical school, participants most commonly reported 6-10, 16-20, and 6-10 h of oncology teaching, respectively. Participants were less confident in their understanding of cancer treatment than workup/diagnosis or basic science/natural history of cancer (p < 0.01). During the preclinical years, pathologists, scientists/Ph.D.'s, and medical oncologists reportedly performed the majority of teaching, whereas during the clinical clerkships, medical and surgical oncologists reportedly performed the majority of teaching. Radiation oncologists were significantly less involved during both periods (p < 0.01). Most schools did not require any oncology-oriented clerkship. During each mandatory rotation, <20 % of patients had a primary diagnosis of cancer. Oncology education is often underemphasized and fragmented with wide variability in content and structure between medical schools, suggesting a need for reform.
癌症是美国第二大致死原因,但关于医学院校如何向医学生传授肿瘤学知识的数据却极为有限。本研究旨在描述美国医学院校的肿瘤学教育情况。2014年12月至2015年2月期间,向参加美国放射肿瘤学会年会或担任美国医学院协会代表的医学生便利样本发送了电子调查问卷。收集了有关参与者所在医学院校肿瘤学教学各方面的信息。收到了来自28个州的学生的76份回复。在美国六种最常见的死因中,据报道癌症课程所占时间位列第四。在医学院的第一年、第二年和第三年,参与者最常报告的肿瘤学教学时长分别为6 - 10小时、16 - 20小时和6 - 10小时。与癌症检查/诊断或癌症基础科学/自然史相比,参与者对癌症治疗的理解信心较低(p < 0.01)。在临床前阶段,据报道病理学家、科学家/博士和肿瘤内科医生承担了大部分教学工作,而在临床实习期间,据报道肿瘤内科医生和外科肿瘤医生承担了大部分教学工作。在这两个阶段,放射肿瘤学家的参与度明显较低(p < 0.01)。大多数学校没有要求任何以肿瘤学为导向的临床实习。在每次强制轮转期间,<20%的患者主要诊断为癌症。肿瘤学教育往往未得到充分重视且碎片化,医学院校之间在内容和结构上存在很大差异,这表明需要进行改革。